Has anyone compared BMW M Roadster to the Boxster S?

[Adam]

He said he was just going use the car like every other car so the boxster S might be over-kill and not the best choice. An M3 cabbie will get you to from A to B more comfortably and it's more practical. For just cruising I think the M3 Cabbie would maybe be a better choice. You might want to take a test drive to see if it suits your needs better than the both of the cars mentioned above.

[Push]

Originally Posted by Adam

He said he was just going use the car like every other car so the boxster S might be over-kill and not the best choice. An M3 cabbie will get you to from A to B more comfortably and it's more practical. For just cruising I think the M3 Cabbie would maybe be a better choice. You might want to take a test drive to see if it suits your needs better than the both of the cars mentioned above.

Thanks for all of the posts guys.

And Adam I should have been more clear with my "drive it like a regular car" statement. I drive all of my cars harder than your average person. I can and do corner as quickly as possible {for the car I'm in at that moment} and I like acceleration as much as anyone else. That said, I'm not looking for the fastest car, I'm looking for the best handling car {within my price range} because I think any new car that can handle this well will already be quick, it just goes with the class.

[phrankandbeanz]

If I had to make it a daily driver, I would get a m3 cab because I think it is just more practical for everyday use. With the boxster, a trip to costco could be a hassle. I love my boxster, but I feel that it is more a second car then a primary car.

[Push]

Originally Posted by phrankandbeanz

If I had to make it a daily driver, I would get a m3 cab because I think it is just more practical for everyday use. With the boxster, a trip to costco could be a hassle. I love my boxster, but I feel that it is more a second car then a primary car.

That car doesn't do much for me in the looks department.