I don't get it.... - 986 Forum - The Community for Porsche Boxster & Cayman Owners

recycledsixtie · 03-22-2013, 05:32 AM

Doing what I do a lot - that is browsing through the new car ads for the Boxster. Wondering why there are so many PDK transmissions on the 2013 Boxsters as opposed to manual transmissions. Not that I want to buy a new one now but Porsche must think they are going to sell lots of PDK Boxsters. I can understand if you live in a large city like LA or New York but the smaller cities I would take a manual trans. and save $3k in the process. Who is going to buy all these PDKs? Your thoughts please?

Mark_T · 03-22-2013, 05:38 AM

Could be a sign of an aging demographic. I would prefer a manual transmission, but as I get older and my knees get progressively worse I may find that I have no choice but to make the swap to PDK.

ekam · 03-22-2013, 06:43 AM

Baby boomers are getting older and Asians can't drive.

Crono0001 · 03-22-2013, 07:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ekam

Baby boomers are getting older and Asians can't drive.

That's because Americans only race us in straight lines

lifeisgood · 03-22-2013, 09:50 AM

Ekam; Asian can't drive....offended

recycledsixtie · 03-23-2013, 06:12 AM

If you track the car and want to be fastest then PDK may be the way to go. For many of us(most?)who don't track then I think the manual trans. is fine for the street. It is the buyer's choice. Perhaps for busy city driving and if I had bad knees PDK would be the way to go. Each one to their own.

lifeisgood · 03-22-2013, 10:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ekam

Baby boomers are getting older and Asians can't drive.

Asians can't drive??? come on have you seen Fast and Furious; Tokyo Drift...lol

Porsche Chick · 03-22-2013, 02:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lifeisgood

Asians can't drive??? come on have you seen Fast and Furious; Tokyo Drift...lol

One of my all-time favorite car movies.

If they could just take out that stupid muscle car, it would be perfect.

coreseller · 03-25-2013, 05:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ekam

Baby boomers are getting older and Asians can't drive.

That made me chuckle, I love it. To take it one step further, what would an Asian Hairdresser who sold Mary Kay who happened to have a gimp left knee drive? Probably a lowered Speed Yellow 2000 S with a full body kit.

JFP is right, PDK is the future for Porsche as alternate versions are for other high end makes, the clutch pedal is being completely phased out. In less than a decade the manual option will be a thing of the past, get on the train or get left behind. I have not driven one (PDK) but I haven't heard a negative thing from guys that I respect who have.

Johnny Danger · 03-25-2013, 05:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by coreseller

That made me chuckle, I love it. To take it one step further, what would an Asian Hairdresser who sold Mary Kay who happened to have a gimp left knee drive? Probably a lowered Speed Yellow 2000 S with a full body kit.

JFP is right, PDK is the future for Porsche as alternate versions are for other high end makes, the clutch pedal is being completely phased out. In less than a decade the manual option will be a thing of the past, get on the train or get left behind. I have not driven one (PDK) but I haven't heard a negative thing from guys that I respect who have.

You meant Herbal Life, not Mary Kay right ?

coreseller · 03-25-2013, 06:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Johnny Danger

You meant Herbal Life, not Mary Kay right ?

Low T Clinic Rep? Damn, that didn't take long. Happy Birthday JD.....

ChrisZang · 03-22-2013, 06:47 AM

Oh No!
Not another PDK discussion :dance:

JFP in PA · 03-22-2013, 07:06 AM

Face it guys, without getting into racial comments, "automated sequential gear boxes" (read PDK) are the way the world is moving. Try buying one of the newer super cars from someone like Ferrari with a true manual gearbox in it......you simply can't.

BYprodriver · 03-22-2013, 07:16 AM

Economy of scale. To get a better price on any part you want to have made you have to commit to buy a certain amount, the more you buy the cheaper it is. Porsche then convinces their dealers to order PDKs for their stock.

JFP in PA · 03-22-2013, 07:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BYprodriver

Economy of scale. To get a better price on any part you want to have made you have to commit to buy a certain amount, the more you buy the cheaper it is. Porsche then convinces their dealers to order PDKs for their stock.

Actually, the gearbox section of a PDK is exactly the same as the conventional seven speed manual unit, the PDK just has a wet dual clutch setup and electronic controls. So economy of scale does not come into play.

shadrach74 · 03-22-2013, 11:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JFP in PA

Actually, the gearbox section of a PDK is exactly the same as the conventional seven speed manual unit, the PDK just has a wet dual clutch setup and electronic controls. So economy of scale does not come into play.

I have been singing this tune to the detractors for months. Trying to explain that there is a difference between an automated manual and "manumatic" is like banging you head against a wall... I enjoy PDK a great deal. I'm not ready to give up my clutch pedal yet, but that's my own hang up. I like the gratification that comes with a well executed heal and toe. However I freely admit that with PDK the car simply relieves the driver of the throttle and clutch work and executes both of those functions both faster and smoother than I ever could...and with absolute consistency.

So what I don't get is why people poo poo PDK so much. I was skeptical before I drove one, but was open to the possibilities.

While I look forward to improvements in the driver interface (I'm not a huge fan of +\- stick action), the electronic actuator of the gearbox is a fantastic piece of technology and it will only get better.

Chuck W. · 03-22-2013, 07:13 AM

You can only get a new Porsche Turbo S with PDK. I am afraid in time a six speed stick will be hard to find.

Perfectlap · 03-22-2013, 07:41 AM

PDK is an automatic. Many people don't know how to drive "a stick shift". By offering automatic Porsches they can sell a lot more cars to people who wouldn't ordinarily put a Boxster or a Cayman at the top of their list. Namely women who for the most part, of course not all, avoid anything that isn't automatic while their incomes have been steadily climbing in the professional ranks. Porsche can't leave money on the table, they have to bring in more of these female buyers who have the means.

The other thing, the Boxster is not a chick car. Never has been -- nor any typically manually equipped roadster. The Boxster is largely an older man's car. A car that he buys once the kids are out of the house. While they're still in the house he buys a Carrera, two adults in the front and two young kids in the back. Older men are not as opposed to the stick shift as women, but if offered convenience or old school, most will choose convenience. Automatic Porsches reel in more female and older buyers no doubt about it.
Outside of North America, I feel most self-made wealthy learned to drive a stick shift well before the typical American. So I'm not so sure that PDK is intended to cater to Chinese billionaires so much as the brand prestiege will lure them in.

The third element is getting their money back on this strangely engineered PDK contraption that even Porsche mechanics don't know so well. At this point they've probably hit that mark and its all gravy from here forward. Equipping a Boxster, Panamera Coupe (aka Carrera) or Panamera sedan with PDK over 7 speed allows Porsche to do what they do best, mark up/inflate the price of car for a customer base that buys first and looks at the bill later. And for the really high end and powerful, like the GT3, I'm thinking that a PDK equipped car will lead to a healthier drivetrain since it won't be mistreated by the driver as much, at those repair prices I can live with a 991 PDK GT3 RS 4.0

The fact that an automatic Porsche is now quicker around places like the N-ring than a 7 mt is just extra sugar on top for Porsche's marketing department.

Personally, I'm of the opinion that in about a year or two Porsche is going to let it out that those paddles on the side of the steering really never were connected to anything. Strictly for novelty purposes, like some non-functioning gauge on your dash or non-functioning air inlet on the bodwork. The car was already starting the upshift or downshift by the time you clicked that PDK paddle. But it makes the driver feel like he's still at the party. It will be a huge brew-ha ha.

schnellman · 03-22-2013, 08:19 AM

Let us all face Stuttgart and offer a silent prayer that Boxsters will always be available with manual transmissions.

tonycarreon · 03-22-2013, 08:41 AM

the GT3 will only be available with PDK and electronic steering.

“We wanted the most emotional car with the most driver involvement we could produce, because nobody needs a GT3. What we’ve ended up with is a system that feels like a full-on race car sequential transmission. We honestly believe that there’s nothing a traditional manual gearbox can give you that this PDK can’t.” - Andreas Preuninger, Porsche’s head of GT Production