2004 Boxster S v 2005 Boxster

[Brucelee]

Yes, I would you suggest you drive both several times if possible.

[UKBXSTR]

Well the 987 is so much more solid than the older 986.

Tried a987S this wek, and compared to my 04 2.7 986 it is a world away in terms of build quality. Interior is so much better (albeit a few trim woes reported on early cars).

The gearchange is much shorter and more chunky (albeit not really any more precise)

The performance didn't blow me away (280 bhp vs my 228) but i wasn't paying a lot of attention to the speedo at the time.

All told the 987 is a much better car

[PDX-986S]

For what it's worth, I love my '04 S, but have not driven the '05 standard or S. The choices you list are between two used cars. A third option--you might still be able to find a new '04 S at a dealership out there. I did in February, and got a good deal, I think ($46k vs. $60K sticker, with 18 in. carrera, bose, xenon). Don't know how that compares to used prices, or if there are still new '04s sitting in lots in August.