2nd Gear Slip-out CMS Shift Arrester

[3_Angels]

So does anyone have experience with the Shift Arrester from CMS? California Motorsports - Porsche Boxster 986 transmission section

[BYprodriver]

I love mine, it gives a noticable improvement in shifting especially 2nd gear. (6-speed)

Install requires removing tail housing, which is easy, reinstalling tail housing is very difficult. It includes a new detent like the G-box 2nd gear popout fix.

Call CMS & they will answer any questions you have about these transmissions.

[Brad Roberts]

You will be upset when you find out: the shift arrester didn't solve the problem

To properly fix your issue? You'll need a new second gear and slider, you'll need to repair or replace the tail housing

[3_Angels]

Originally Posted by Brad Roberts

You will be upset when you find out: the shift arrester didn't solve the problem

To properly fix your issue? You'll need a new second gear and slider, you'll need to repair or replace the tail housing

Thanks gentlmen: Based on comments, I replaced second gear, slider, and synchronizer rings for second gear. I repaired the tail housing. All back together tonight. 2002BoxsterSTransmissionRebuildDecember2011Revisio n3.pdf

[jaykay]

dude! does your woman allow 6-speeds on the coffee table? if so I bow before your greatness

[3_Angels]

Originally Posted by jaykay

dude! does your woman allow 6-speeds on the coffee table? if so I bow before your greatness

Wouldn't that be nice. No such luck. My Gold Crown is in the living room, the transmission is finished and back in the garage. I'm doing a DOF IMS along with DMF clutch job when parts arrive. I'm adding 600 sq ft pool room along with a lap pool attached to the house. When all that entertainment is completed, maybe we can be fortunate enough to attract a vibrant 65 year old female companion. (I'm retired)

[CaliforniaMotorsport]

Originally Posted by Brad Roberts

You will be upset when you find out: the shift arrester didn't solve the problem

To properly fix your issue? You'll need a new second gear and slider, you'll need to repair or replace the tail housing

We don't claim our shift arrester will fix a pop out problem. It will help prevent future ones from happening provided the 2nd gear synchro teeth and slider are in good shape.

[Gelbster]

Thanks for the clarification.It is a great solution to the #1 reason(??) for a gearbox rebuild.
Here is the part that CMS were too modest to link:
CMS 996 SHIFT ARRESTER – California Motorsports Inc
Yes it is expensive($200) but until someone comes up with a better/much cheaper part it is the best solution?

[Trendy996]

Gbox also offers a second gear popout solution. I have one in my 996. Works wonders but, inthink it's a little more than 200.

[Gelbster]

Hey Trendy - yes, I read about the gbox item . Curious why you chose theirs rather than CMS or why not both???
Thanks for any insight.

[Trendy996]

An educated guess would tell me that the cms is only good for non worn trans and I've seen the gbox cure peoples trans that is starting to see the problem. Now if the problem is left unattended then there really is no cure other than rebuilding that area. As for using both I think that would be over kill but it also wouldn't hurt. All the cms does is fully engage the gear.

This opinion is just my observation from the designs.

[BYprodriver]

Originally Posted by Gelbster

Hey Trendy - yes, I read about the gbox item . Curious why you chose theirs rather than CMS or why not both???
Thanks for any insight.

The CMS shift arrester is a billett replacement for the oem part & includes a modified detent similar to the G-box, so no need to buy both.

[Gelbster]

Kudos to Byprodriver -the first and only Forum member to explain this.
Thank you for the education!

[CaliforniaMotorsport]

Originally Posted by Gelbster

Hey Trendy - yes, I read about the gbox item . Curious why you chose theirs rather than CMS or why not both???
Thanks for any insight.

Both cannot be used in conjunction as it will exacerbate the problem.