What to Buy???

[drburton]

I'm a bit Porsche biased so I would say go with the Boxster S, I think you may be disappointed with the power on the Base Boxster.

Just another consideration, the 05 Boxster S is almost identical to the 06 and you can get a low mileage one at a very good price. You can pick one up in the low 40's. I'm being a bit self serving here since I plan to sell mine in the Spring.

All of these choices are nice cars though, so I think you will be happy.