Should I trade in my Boxster for a Cayman?

[VGM911]

Originally Posted by 911monty

So let me get this straight. You are considering giving them your car, since all you'll get is what you put in the recent upgrades/repair, Just So you don't have to drive it in the winter. AND you're going to pay a markup to buy a car that is essentially the same that you will drive in the winter??? Only now you don't know it's condition and may have to invest again to get it up to par? AND you bought in January and have never experienced fall in the drop top?
My vote would be to buy a hardtop and winter wheels and tires and drive the box in the winter if these are your options, since you were going to give it away anyway, why care? But if you have to give the dealer a steal, offer it for the trade in value here. I'm sure lots here would love to give you $8k.....:roll eyes:

In summary "No"

PS ARE YOU CRAZY????? Or your stocks doing better than mine? Glad to help.....

I agree with 911monty. Keep the Boxster and put a hardtop on it AND good, winter tires.