Boxster Base vs S

[fatmike]

I've owned 3 BMWs over the years and I'm a big fan of the e46 M3 -- I almost bought one, but I am very happy with my Boxster. In hindsight, the M would have been a mistake for me.


The S has the 3.2L engine, upgraded brakes with red brake calipers, upgraded suspension (springs, anti-roll bar, dampers, etc.), 6 speed manual, and some trim pieces (dual tail pipe, etc.).


I think you should be able to get both of those cars for well under $20K. Drive them both and decide if you need the extra power. The key to the Boxster is tossability -- the S weighs more and its different. Some swear by it, some prefer the base.


Keep in mind that time is equally important than miles on many of the maintenance items on a Boxster (you're gonna end up doing them all anyway).