[itsnotanova]

I love autobody and painting! Mostly the painting part because sanding can get old. I got your PM wanting just one bumperette. Is it to replace that one? I don't see anything wrong with the one you have? Either one you get will need work to get ready for paint. In fact I think you'll need less work on that one vs a bare black one I could send you. My suggestion is throw a coat of etching primer over it (not sure if it's needed on rubber, but it couldn't hurt) and then start using lots of filling primer. I'd probably finish with a sealer.