986 Forum - The Community for Porsche Boxster & Cayman Owners

986 Forum - The Community for Porsche Boxster & Cayman Owners (http://986forum.com/forums/)
-   Performance and Technical Chat (http://986forum.com/forums/performance-technical-chat/)
-   -   Odd problem, simple solution (http://986forum.com/forums/performance-technical-chat/70303-odd-problem-simple-solution.html)

JayG 12-04-2017 06:51 PM

Odd problem, simple solution
 
A couple of weeks a go, I went to go for a drive, started her up and she was running rough. A few seconds later, the CEL popped on. Now I know I have a bad cat, so that's not so unusual, the rough idle was.

Connected my OBD2 adapter and it was throwing a CYL 5 misfire code. Shut it down and since I have 92k on the clock and had a cyl 3 missfire about a year ago, I figured it was a coil pack going bad. I ordered a new one online and went to put it in last night and when I check the coil pack, both bolts were missing! It was also loose.

Pushed it in, found a pair of bolts from the last one I replaced and guess what??? Runs just like it is supposed to.

Now I have a spare coil pack for my track box right next to my spare ABS sensor

tlc356 12-05-2017 05:13 AM

So who installed the pac that became loose? LOL-don't answer. Tom

JayG 12-05-2017 05:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tlc356 (Post 557048)
So who installed the pac that became loose? LOL-don't answer. Tom

some German named Hans

Factory install

thstone 12-05-2017 09:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JayG (Post 557051)
some German named Hans

Factory install

Jay, I think that Tom is asking who most recently replaced the spark plugs. That would have probably been the last time that the coil pack bolts were removed and re-installed. Whoever did the work might have forgot to torque them. :)

Glad that it was an easy fix.

NewArt 12-05-2017 05:03 PM

I remember one time I had a similar situation with the inner axle flange bolts. I had changed the boots and after a few weeks the bolts loosened off. Fortunately, I caught it in time! Perhaps a few drops of blue loctite would help?

Boxstard 12-05-2017 06:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NewArt (Post 557122)
I remember one time I had a similar situation with the inner axle flange bolts. I had changed the boots and after a few weeks the bolts loosened off. Fortunately, I caught it in time! Perhaps a few drops of blue loctite would help?

I think you are supposed to re-torque axle bolts after 500 miles, if I recall.

particlewave 12-05-2017 09:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Boxstard (Post 557137)
I think you are supposed to re-torque axle bolts after 500 miles, if I recall.

That would be counterproductive as it would break the thread locker that you should have applied.
Re-torquing the axle flange bolts is not recommended.

I've read of these breaking loose after removal/installation (in one case even breaking the transmission mount point off of the trans case), so was wary when I did my clutch. I used blue thread locker and a touch of clear red enamel on the head of the bolts (a blob that was on the side of the head and the mating surface) so I could check periodically to see if they broke loose. That was a year ago and none ever did.

JayG 12-06-2017 05:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thstone (Post 557070)
Jay, I think that Tom is asking who most recently replaced the spark plugs. That would have probably been the last time that the coil pack bolts were removed and re-installed. Whoever did the work might have forgot to torque them. :)

Glad that it was an easy fix.

haha I was being a little funny with my Hans comment.

In thinking about it, I had the plugs replaced almost 4 years ago, shortly after I bought the car. It was before I really started to wrench the car myself and the guy who did the plug replacement is an Uber-Mechanic for Porsche cars. He is the type that can rebuild your motor without looking in the book for clearances and torque settings.

I guess a couple of years of tracking and AX loosened them up. I going to check them all this weekend to double check tightness

BFeller 12-06-2017 06:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by particlewave (Post 557151)
That would be counterproductive as it would break the thread locker that you should have applied.
Re-torquing the axle flange bolts is not recommended.

I've read of these breaking loose after removal/installation (in one case even breaking the transmission mount point off of the trans case), so was wary when I did my clutch. I used blue thread locker and a touch of clear red enamel on the head of the bolts (a blob that was on the side of the head and the mating surface) so I could check periodically to see if they broke loose. That was a year ago and none ever did.

Nice idea on the paint blob.

911monty 12-06-2017 08:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Boxstard (Post 557137)
I think you are supposed to re-torque axle bolts after 500 miles, if I recall.

Quote:

Originally Posted by particlewave (Post 557151)
That would be counterproductive as it would break the thread locker that you should have applied.
Re-torquing the axle flange bolts is not recommended.

I've read of these breaking loose after removal/installation (in one case even breaking the transmission mount point off of the trans case), so was wary when I did my clutch. I used blue thread locker and a touch of clear red enamel on the head of the bolts (a blob that was on the side of the head and the mating surface) so I could check periodically to see if they broke loose. That was a year ago and none ever did.

If the axle bolts were installed correctly then there is no reason to not recheck torque, especially for the first time DIY'er. As long as you check to the original torque value there will be no additional movement. However if it does move then they got loose for some reason , dirt, corrosion or incorrect tightening sequence etc. and you will be thankful for the chance to correct the problem.
I checked mine about a week after i C/O the output seal and again when I installed the Koni FSDs. No movement either time. Bonus tip: This task is made especially easy with a 3' extension.

particlewave 12-06-2017 10:06 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by 911monty (Post 557257)
If the axle bolts were installed correctly then there is no reason to not recheck torque, especially for the first time DIY'er. As long as you check to the original torque value there will be no additional movement. However if it does move then they got loose for some reason , dirt, corrosion or incorrect tightening sequence etc. and you will be thankful for the chance to correct the problem.
I checked mine about a week after i C/O the output seal and again when I installed the Koni FSDs. No movement either time. Bonus tip: This task is made especially easy with a 3' extension.

Aside from the linked post below, I read on another forum specifically to use medium thread locker and leave them be because trying to tighten again could weaken the thread locker. I can't find it now, but I recall it being a reputable source (possibly JR).

http://986forum.com/forums/performance-technical-chat/64679-help-removing-cv-joint-bolts.html

911monty 12-07-2017 07:36 AM

Funny. I thought about linking that post or adding something like "I know a professional shop such as JFP's does not bring back to re-torque" etc. I did say if "done correctly" where JFP says "proper installation is critical",(disclaimer: I am a fan of JFP's terminology) I think meaning parts are clean, proper tightening sequence etc. This may or not be true with a DIYer since you don't know their skill level or attention to detail.
So what is said is, that if it was done correctly the first time, and you do not exceed the original torque value, then there will be no further movement of the fastener. ESPECIALLY if you used blue loctite which has now hardened and further increases the torque necessary to move the fastener. So if you are absolutely confident in your installation then don't re-torque, but if that one spec of sand/rust finally grinds down and the bolts get loose....Now I never think about mine, How long and often are you going to check that red paint? Of course I also use a torque wrench when installing my wheels and check them again after a few days, or for that matter whenever I happen to be walking around with a torque wrench and it is convenient.

Something I used to do when installing ARP rod bolts was after using a stretch gage to torque I'd throw a torque wrench set slightly below desired value on to verify. Totally unnecessary but also doesn't hurt.

Boxstard 12-07-2017 06:20 PM

I know that you guys out there are experts and do right things. But I personally never used locktite on axle bolts wrenching multiple cars I own(ed) and never had issues.... Just degrease bolt/ thread well and use torque wrench, then retorque once later. Actually do not recall any bolts got loosened up.

I do not recall my reference books (Bentley and 101 Projects) mention to use the locktite. Maybe shops use it as it is not convenient for customers to come back for retorque and just to be safe when they don't?

particlewave 12-08-2017 07:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Boxstard (Post 557338)
I know that you guys out there are experts and do right things. But I personally never used locktite on axle bolts wrenching multiple cars I own(ed) and never had issues.... Just degrease bolt/ thread well and use torque wrench, then retorque once later. Actually do not recall any bolts got loosened up.

I do not recall my reference books (Bentley and 101 Projects) mention to use the locktite. Maybe shops use it as it is not convenient for customers to come back for retorque and just to be safe when they don't?

Not using thread locker on a critical fastener, like an axle bolt, is a mistake.
Do it right. Do it once. ;)

Nothing more to say...

Boxstard 12-08-2017 11:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by particlewave (Post 557368)
Not using thread locker on a critical fastener, like an axle bolt, is a mistake.
Do it right. Do it once. ;)

Nothing more to say...

The question is if it is designed to use loctite or not, and I think it is not. I did not notice any loctite residue on bolt threads if originally applied from the factory.

I guess IMSB was not designed to explode before the warranty either so it's at my own risk... but I do not lose sleep over it, after putting 5,000 miles since the retorque 8 months ago.

911monty 12-08-2017 05:25 PM

Sad Really.. Understandable for a shop since time=money. Which I think really is the point of JFP's post. Hell I work on mine for recreation. But the question really is, is it worth an investment of 5 minutes of your time to verify, or risk investing in a flatbed and any collateral damage. If it's tight no harm no foul. If it's loose retorque and carry on. If it moves and you used loctite, nothing on the box says one time use only. Pull each bolt clean, reapply, re torque and hoist a cold one. :cheers: And if you're so sure done right done once, what's the red paint for. Sheesh. Let's just keep these things on the road.


Sorry for the hijack JayG.

particlewave 12-08-2017 06:39 PM

The red paint is for redundancy since the axle bolts are notorious for backing out and/or snapping off. It's also convenient for a quick 10 second visual inspection through the wheel instead of all the work of jacking the car up, getting tools out and getting under the car. ;)

911monty 12-08-2017 06:43 PM

Yeah whatever. i could fall back on yeah I did mine and nothing failed therefore you don't need to. But if one person followed my smug advice and something failed and caused damage they couldn't afford to repair, that's unacceptable. To loosely quote Gelbster "Do no harm" and yeah you could check every 50 freakin miles if you wanted since nothing would be harmed.

particlewave 12-08-2017 06:50 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Axles swinging around after breaking free of the output flange can do some damage.

Not meaning to give anyone a hard time, just better safe than sorry. Whatever makes you feel best, do that. :)

911monty 12-08-2017 06:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by particlewave (Post 557419)
Axles swinging around after breaking free of the output flange can do some damage.

Exactly.:cheers:


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 01:42 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2024 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Pelican Parts Website