Which would you buy ?

[gsy4771]

I found this thread very interesting because I'm also in the market. Well maybe not in the market until next year but appears we have a similar budget.

I think I would lean toward #1 just because it is a newer model and an S. If I were to get that one I would immediately replace the bearing/clutch just because that IMS concerns me and I wouldn't be able to enjoy the car. The mileage mildly concerns me so I guess it may have some maintenance bills coming. I have read about suspension refreshing so something to think about.

I also liked the 2001 because it appears to have a lot of maintenance has been completed. A lot depends on the type of IMS bearing that was used. If it was the 'upgraded' bearing it would increase my interest but if it was OEM I wouldn't think about it. IMS bearing just bothers me. The 2001 becomes very interesting comes down another $2k, I'd probably get it and replace the bearing with the upgraded option if it doesn't already have it installed.

Good luck and let us know what you decide!

[mikefocke]

Part 101 212 sure doesn't look like an IMS seal to me. Looks like it is a RMS on the end of the crankshaft. You can look up the parts on the PET pdf that Porsche offers here.

My second Boxster was hit in the rear and an insurance claim was made against the other driver so I'm sure carfax would show it. Superficial bumper damage of over $1k but an affect on handling, no. Better than new after repair. My buyer absolutely didn't question it when I made disclosure and I was prepared with post accident pictures.

The more you know about the car, the more you can pay. The less the bigger the gamble.

[78F350]

Originally Posted by mikefocke

Part 101 212 sure doesn't look like an IMS seal to me. Looks like it is a RMS on the end of the crankshaft. You can look up the parts on the PET pdf that Porsche offers here....

Mike, Ignore the yellow highlight on that receipt. Look a few line above for:
996-105-024-01
996-105-112-01
999-707-392-40

Originally Posted by Krooked

There are some who would argue the seal should simply be removed, since the bearing itself is likely to get oil soaked (and therefore loose any grease it's packed with). the thought here is, without a seal, the IMSB would get far more lubrication. So, depending on who you ask, the seal being replaced can be either a good thing or a bad one. ...

In this case, I don't think that the grease seal on the bearing is relevant. The work was done on the IMS flange seal and o-ring.
________________
I'd buy the '04.
I like:

tires newer, sport seats, sport exhaust, Carrera wheels...

The mileage difference between them is not significant to me. More important is knowing it was owned by an enthusiast:

In speaking to the mechanic of number 1 he told me a lot about the owner. A 70 year old man who only buys the best and really takes care of his cars. Has about 10 I'm told. That one has all the options I want, as it was heavily optioned

IMS... If it worries you change it ASAP, if not, wait 'till it needs other service.
I'll be surprised if that one doesn't sell while you are still considering it.

P.S. PPI, PPI, PPI

[pinksnyper]

Originally Posted by 78F350

Mike, Ignore the yellow highlight on that receipt. Look a few line above for:
996-105-024-01
996-105-112-01
999-707-392-40



In this case, I don't think that the grease seal on the bearing is relevant. The work was done on the IMS flange seal and o-ring.
________________
I'd buy the '04.
I like:
The mileage difference between them is not significant to me. More important is knowing it was owned by an enthusiast:
IMS... If it worries you change it ASAP, if not, wait 'till it needs other service.
I'll be surprised if that one doesn't sell while you are still considering it.

P.S. PPI, PPI, PPI

Thanks, the car is mine pending PPI next week. It was my favorite of many cars I've been considering. I'll see what the PPI yields and report back!

[pinksnyper]

Originally Posted by gsy4771

I found this thread very interesting because I'm also in the market. Well maybe not in the market until next year but appears we have a similar budget.

I think I would lean toward #1 just because it is a newer model and an S. If I were to get that one I would immediately replace the bearing/clutch just because that IMS concerns me and I wouldn't be able to enjoy the car. The mileage mildly concerns me so I guess it may have some maintenance bills coming. I have read about suspension refreshing so something to think about.

I also liked the 2001 because it appears to have a lot of maintenance has been completed. A lot depends on the type of IMS bearing that was used. If it was the 'upgraded' bearing it would increase my interest but if it was OEM I wouldn't think about it. IMS bearing just bothers me. The 2001 becomes very interesting comes down another $2k, I'd probably get it and replace the bearing with the upgraded option if it doesn't already have it installed.

Good luck and let us know what you decide!

It had a bunch of rear strut replacement last year, based on the records.

[gsy4771]

Out of curiosity where how/where did you find these cars? I have had a hard time finding cars for sale by owner most everything I found was for sale by dealers.

[pinksnyper]

Originally Posted by gsy4771

Out of curiosity where how/where did you find these cars? I have had a hard time finding cars for sale by owner most everything I found was for sale by dealers.

An ungodly daily management of cars.com, autotrader, eBay, and Craigslist

[pinksnyper]

Forgot to mention that the 04 has the 030 sport suspension, litronics, and pretty much every other available option at nearly 67k MSRP. So yeah I'm going to PPI this week and hopefully post pics soon , proclaiming my official real entry into this forum .thank you for the well informed replies.

[Ciao]

Originally Posted by pinksnyper

Forgot to mention that the 04 has the 030 sport suspension, litronics, and pretty much every other available option at nearly 67k MSRP. So yeah I'm going to PPI this week and hopefully post pics soon , proclaiming my official real entry into this forum .thank you for the well informed replies.

We'll.....that makes the decision easier. #1

[pinksnyper]

Originally Posted by Ciao

We'll.....that makes the decision easier. #1

PPI came back very positive. I am flying down Wednesday to pick the car up and drive it home. Will post pictures in New member area when I do. Thanks for the tips everyone!

[GTA_G20]

Congrats. And enjoy thoroughly