Which is a better deal? Is it priced fairly? HELP ASAP - Need to pick one

[Ronzi]

You might want to look at the listings on cars.com. There are 873 Boxsters listed for sale, nationwide. You should be able to get a good idea of competitive pricing, remembering that asking prices are almost always a little high, and a long list of options don't usually add much to the value of the car.
The Kelly Blue Book prices on the net seem to me to always be 'way high, the cars.com Black Book prices similar but less so.
I like the NADA used car guide prices the best, I guess because they tend to be the lowest. At least that's how I looked at it when I was buying.
You are definately looking at the best color combination.
Ronzi
'99 Box
Speed Yellow/Black