Barkin... go see Mark Miller's (sr & jr) shop - Greater Pittsburgh Collision Works -
* Greater Pittsburgh Collision Works * Corey in the front handles all their estimates but they do great work. Not always cheapest but fair based on quality of job. I suspect, barring anything too catastrophic, they can repair and respray your damage so you'll never even notice w/o having to replace. They're on Flaugherty Run ~ 5min from Sewickley Bridge and do most of Sewickley's work. If you fly a lot, they have free pick up and delivery at Globe too.
Good luck