Buying help - Which one would be a better choice?

Dave, the lower mileage car clearly states the car is a 6-speed manual.

In a lot of ways, both cars should have similar maintenance, since a lot of things are also based on time, not just mileage.

For example brake fluid flush every 2 years. A yearly oil change regardless of mileage. Both cars should have had the plugs change since they are 6-7 years old. About the only difference would be something like the serpt. belt. The higher milegae car should have this done at the 60K.