Big wheels =more easily damaged?

[zemmo]

Originally Posted by rick3000

In Alaska, yah you can break your rims. But normal DD driving in most other places, there is no need to worry about breaking your rims. I have never heard of anyone having problems but I can see your point, it depends on where your driving. If you want 19" go for it, but get them on a Boxster!

Hey, Rick, I really am trying to decide between a Boxster and a Cayman. I know you guys are roadster lovers, but other than the top (or not) is there any reason to favor one over the other?

Interestingly, on ebay at least, it seems that one can buy a Cayman cheaper than a Boxster. A couple of nice, low-mileage coupes sold yesterday, both 2006 S models, one moderately equipped, one loaded, for 40k and 46k, respectively. I don't think you can buy a good 2006 Boxster S for anywhere near 40k, but maybe I'm wrong. Input?