[Retroman1969]

I'll bet it pops out easily from behind when the bumper cover is pulled and heated. Any scuffing to the paint, just hit it with some polish and wax.
Several years ago, I came out to the parking lot to find the whole right rear quarter of my 1972 Pontiac Catalina convertible caved in. Since there were no creases, my body shop popped it out and buffed it for $35.

I know how you feel though. It still sickens me how no one has any common sense anymore or takes any responsibility for themselves.