I hit a deer last November with my wife's 2005 BMW 325 xi. State Farm did a wonderful job paying the claim. The body shop I go to got them to replace everything that needed it, as well as the windshield washer fluid reservoir, which started leaking a month after the car was out of the body shop.
I also crashed a 1993 Honda CBR900RR motorcycle years ago, and State Farm paid me to make it like new again. I was even able to order the parts from Honda and do all the work myself, since there's no Honda dealer where I live.
No problems with State Farm (yet
)!