I'm so sorry to see that. It just irks me all the more to see such a beauty attacked by a boring POS driven by a complete moron.
I'd probably buy it back and use it as a spare parts mule for the next one. Unfortunately it's the victims that usually get screwed in the end. We never get what really have in the vehicles. Fortunately there's plenty nice ones out there of all colors and trims so hopefully you'll fall in love all over again.
On another note, it looks like the Boxster kicked the other car's ass! These cars are tougher than I thought!