I had WeatherTech All Weather mats in my 2002 Boxster S, they fit fine.
Strangely enough, when I ordered a set for my 1996 911 they fit HORRIBLY! They were indeed available through the matrix where you choose model / year, looks like they still are. When I got them and put in the car I sent WeatherTech an email regarding their poor fit, they responded to send them a picture which I promptly did.
Two weeks go by without a response, resent email with pics to customer service and copied their president David MacNeil on it. No response from that either which REALLY burned me since Mr. MacNeil seems quite adept at preaching his values through their ads, made me nauseous.
For whatever reason about a year later I was cleaning out the interior of the 911 and got worked up all over again regarding WT's handling of my complaint. Shot off another email to them copying the BBB and our state AG (like he really wanted to get involved lol) out of frustration. About a week later they refunded my Paypal for the set plus shipping.
Have since bought a set of Cocomats and couldn't be happier.
Welcome To Cocomats.com