Consider giving these guys a try:
http://www.wheelcollision.com/ They're in Bath, just north of Allentown.
I've been using them for 15+ years. They have a huge inventory of refinished wheels that they sell outright or on exchange, and of course they can refinish yours. Nice guys, no BS, great work that they stand behind, quick turnaround and fair prices posted on their website. I'm sure if you emailed them photos they could give you a very good idea of what your wheels would cost to repair/refinish.