View Single Post
Old 06-05-2008, 06:40 AM   #11
Kevfra
Registered User
 
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: San Francisco
Posts: 66
As someone who has driven, and worked on, MANY German cars for thirty years, I have some thoughts.

First specifically on Mercedes is that hey have engineered too many single points of failure Why should a smog device failure shut down the engine rather than just throw a light? I have often said that given my choice to make a nonstop drive coast to coast with either a new Mercedes or new Yugo I'd choose the Yugo. Because the Mercedes has such poor reliability. And I have driven them for thirty years! High end too, always S cars. But they are too overengineered.

In general the Germans are gadget freaks, and they love to make complicated gadgets. Just go to germany and look at a store door, or any other commonplace item, and it'll have twenty moving parts rather than a hinge. Mind you that device will last forever with some rebuilding rather than replacing - and that is their mindset. It's not that they make junk, it's that they try to go too far too fast, be the first, be the most innovative etc.

I love their cars (well not VW & Audi) but I am well aware you can't be a one car family if that one car is German.
Kevfra is offline   Reply With Quote