Well this forum saved my a@@ again!
I'm getting ready to change to Silverstar's. I went to get my toolkit (assuming it was in the front of the spare) and found an empty black bag

I assumed it was the toolkit bag and that the tools were gone.
Went to Ebay and found one from LA Dismantlers -- $200!

I did notice though that the bag I found was too small to be the tool bag.
Based on the "behind the tire" info in this thread, I decided to take a look. Sure enough, there it was snuggly tucked above the jack in the foam insert :dance:
Not only is it complete, my guess is that it may have never been opened. There were some white plastic sheets and a yellow bag with plastic gloves (german instructions) in with the tools. Anyone know if those came with the toolkit originally?