986 Forum - The Community for Porsche Boxster & Cayman Owners

986 Forum - The Community for Porsche Boxster & Cayman Owners (http://986forum.com/forums/)
-   Boxster General Discussions (http://986forum.com/forums/boxster-general-discussions/)
-   -   Mid / rear engine flops... (http://986forum.com/forums/boxster-general-discussions/58039-mid-rear-engine-flops.html)

Timco 07-23-2015 06:18 PM

Mid / rear engine flops...
 
What comes to mind??

Fiat Bertone
Toyota MR2
Pontiac Fierro

I used to really like the Fiat.

litespeedp 07-23-2015 06:27 PM

I liked the FIAT X/19 too.I test drove the first year 1974 with the small nerf bumpers at the dealership and liked it a lot.

The great thing about car clubs and forums is that the fixes for the big things that soured the public are discovered and remedied with time.The early Ford De Tomaso Pantera's had cooling and A/C etc problems and now the owners get great support with parts that eliminate the early model problems.

BIGJake111 07-23-2015 06:44 PM

I think early mr-2s are alright, the late model that was on sale at the same time as the boxster was an absolute joke though.

Supposedly the Evora isn't that good of a car particularly for its price.

10/10ths 07-23-2015 06:49 PM

That's easy....
 
...DeLorean.

Finnegan 07-24-2015 12:17 PM

My ex had a first gen SC MR2. It was fun, in a snap oversteer sort of way.

patssle 07-24-2015 02:19 PM

Was there ever a legal issue of the MR2 3rd gen looking too similar to the Boxster? Looks like they ripped off the design.

78F350 07-24-2015 02:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Timco (Post 458427)

Fiat Bertone
Toyota MR2
Pontiac Fierro

I bought an MR2 once just to cut apart and see what was inside ($150). The good parts actually sold pretty quick. Drove it around the yard a couple times (no brakes except for the e-brake).
http://986forum.com/forums/uploads01/MR21437776302.jpg


I think that the X 1/9s were made out of rusty metal at the start and after the first year, it would bleed through the paint:
http://986forum.com/forums/uploads01...1437776550.jpg


A co-worker has a Fiero. He keeps it parked in the back of the parking lot at work. Think he's embarrassed to have it in his driveway.

Wasn't there Ford that came out in the mid to late 80s..? I can't think of the name.

schnellman 07-25-2015 05:12 AM

I had a Lancia Scorpian for a couple years. Loved the handling. Getting parts was like finding a Unicorn.

Chuck W. 07-25-2015 06:31 AM

Don't forget the Corvair... According to Nadar, it was a flop. But there are a lot of enthusiast out there.

http://images.classiccars.com/classi...et_Corvair.jpg

flaps10 07-25-2015 08:31 AM

Do you means sales flop, or the car was a piece of crap?

Keep in mind that one man's flop is another man's bargain. Sort of how I ended up with a cheap Porsche.

I'm going to preface this next part by admitting to the only GM car I've ever owned. My typical opinion of their products is just this side of my thoughts on Chrysler.

Way, way back in the day I fell into a deal for a Fiero (it was a 2 year old '86 model). They were known for bursting into flames and the early models s*** the bed for the entire production run because of clutch problems. GM solutions were weak at best.

On the flip side, it was a very comfortable two seat road tripping car. I'm 6'2" and you could be considerably taller than me and be comfortable. The stock stereo including speakers in the head rests is probably responsible for most of my hearing loss.

Hate it if you want, it was a low slung mid engine car and that always pays in smiles. I even had the most hated 2.5 four cylinder (aka 151cu in "iron duke"). It was a push rod motor that was completely out of breath past 4500 rpm. The gearing however was perfectly spaced so that you could keep the car between it's 4k rpm torque peak and 4400 rpm hp peak at all times. It was possible to maintain some very high speeds in the corners.

The clutch problems were because the pivot shaft was too tight. Curable with a bit of tinkering and a piece of sandpaper.

The tendency to burst into flames was often due to oil starvation in high G turns (my car had amazing rubber and rims). The dry engine would throw a rod and puke what little oil it had left on the exhaust manifold. There were work arounds with large capacity oil filters, running slightly more oil (one recall just gave you a different dip stick to do just that). I kept a halon fire extinguisher in the car but never used it.

Glitchy throttle position sensors were another pain. They failed randomly even if new. The solution was to crack it open and solder three metal tabs to the contacts they were touching and then silicone it shut.

My car broke a head bolt. A head gasket set was $40 and I was back in business.

In the end, not my worst car experience. Cheap to run and still holds my fastest time across the state of Washington (by over 40 minutes).

thstone 07-25-2015 09:12 AM

The early Gen 1 MR2 was essentially a Toyota Cayman. I bought a 1985 MR2 brand new and we drove it 125,000 miles until selling it in 1993.

The 1.6L four cyl had dual overhead cams, 4-valves per cylinder, variable intake, and produced 112hp for 70hp/liter. That engine loved to rev and was reminiscent of a high performance motorcycle engine - which was no surprise because the engine was partly developed by Yamaha.

At this time, the 3.2L Porsche 911 was producing 207hp for 65hp/liter - less than a Toyota! And remember, Toyota (then and now) is not exactly known for squeezing every hp out of an engine. Fairly impressive for the time.

And to the best of my recollection, the MR2 had no intermediate shaft bearing. :) Engines would routinely run past 200,000 miles without a problem.

Handling was exemplary and consistent with a mid-engine sports car. Many a driver (including myself) spun it after being surprised at how quickly it rotated. It was nimble, quick, and incredibly fun to drive.

Of course, the later models became bloated (as is so common) and lost all of the magic that made the early model so fun.

thstone 07-25-2015 09:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by flaps10 (Post 458617)
... Way, way back in the day I fell into a deal for a Fiero...

http://i1114.photobucket.com/albums/...psil050ycr.jpg

78F350 07-25-2015 09:44 AM

Quote:

Wasn't there Ford that came out in the mid to late 80s..? I can't think of the name.
The one I was trying to remember was the XR2, Mercury Capri XR2. Turns out it was front engine & FWD, so not in the category.

leftfield6 07-25-2015 04:57 PM

Yeah, I'm not sure what you are referring to as a "flop"??

I've owned both a 1st Gen MR2 and actually multiple X1/9s. The X1/9 was on the market for 13 years, so it obviously had some success. And the 1st Gen MR2 was an outstanding car for the 1980s. Well balanced, dependable, well built, great in the curves.

I'm not seeing a flop here.

fins 07-25-2015 05:03 PM

i am embarrassed to say that I've have owned a Fiero...

steved0x 07-25-2015 07:31 PM

I had an X 1/9 back in the late 80's when I was 17, bought it for $500 with the money I made working at McDonald's. It was a 4 speed, had no seat belts, and I think it was a 76 or 77. My friend had one and his dad helped me fix it up.

A few years ago remembering the experiences I had driving it led me to searching for another convertible (mid life crisis / divorce present to myself) and that is when I discovered the Boxster.

Timco 07-26-2015 04:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by leftfield6 (Post 458666)
Yeah, I'm not sure what you are referring to as a "flop"??

I've owned both a 1st Gen MR2 and actually multiple X1/9s. The X1/9 was on the market for 13 years, so it obviously had some success. And the 1st Gen MR2 was an outstanding car for the 1980s. Well balanced, dependable, well built, great in the curves.

I'm not seeing a flop here.

Well, can't edit titles.

I figured the Boxster was 18 years of 986 and still made today. That's a winning design that is still in demand. 13 years is a good run but with all production gone, parts still around for any of those? In 10 years? Is about 10 years of production the marker for a good run?

I had a Pinto wagon in high school. Then moms friend parked a Fiero in front of our house and I wanted it bad. She was even selling. Worked payments out to be $72-mo but for my first job at $3.15/hr or something close, that was a decent payment plus insurance. Then in front of my own home, smoke started pouring out the engine bay and the FD was called. Doused that tiny car with water then open hood and wet it down and pull batt. Electrical fire. I was never so pleased to have a Pinto.

paulofto 07-26-2015 07:56 AM

I had a 78 X1/9 from 79 to 85 and it was my daily driver in Edmonton. Bitter winters and all, the little Fiat was a fun car. Never a problem with rust but the electricals were sometimes an adventure. I did all my own work including clutch and transmission stuff and did a little auto crossing up at the old Edmonton Speedway (now long gone). The only thing it lacked was HP but it handled like a slot car. I wish I still had it.

BIGJake111 07-26-2015 10:20 AM

I guess arguably he mid engine Porsche twins, 914, and the nsx may be the only truly successful mid engine affordable cars.

I'm not sure how the vx220 and Opel speedster did or most other lotus based cars as they rarely come stateside. The 4c could end up being remotely successful however I still find it very overpriced.

leftfield6 07-26-2015 11:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Timco (Post 458694)
Well, can't edit titles.
13 years is a good run but with all production gone, parts still around for any of those? In 10 years? Is about 10 years of production the marker for a good run?


Still a few specialty retailers and shops providing parts and service for the "old" Fiat family of cars, The 124 Spider series and the Bertone (X1/9) series were the most popular Fiats, so many parts are still available.

Midwest Bayless in Ohio even offers a conversion kit to put an Acura K20 engine in an X1/9. 210 HP = 0-100 in 14 seconds.

Youtube clip

Luckyed 07-27-2015 05:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 78F350 (Post 458628)
The one I was trying to remember was the XR2, Mercury Capri XR2. Turns out it was front engine & FWD, so not in the category.

Actually, although still not in this category because it was a front engine car, I think he was referring to the Ford EXP and Mercury LN7 (I owned the latter....It handled great but was a POS)

Forgotten Mercury Of The Day: 1982 LN7

BobRickel 07-27-2015 05:41 PM

I have owned most every mid engine car on the market in the last 50 years. Everything from Porsche 914 and 550 Spyder, to Pantera, to Fiat X1/9, to Lotus Europa, to most every year Fiero. I just love mid engined handling. The Fiero started out as a cheap car that was assembled from the spare parts bin but was finally redesigned for a final time for the 1988 model and with the help of GM's new company, Lotus they addressed most every problem including the suspension and then they quit making it halfway through the year. Loved the 11 914's I have owned over the years and they got better with every year and by the time they quit making it in 1976 it was a pretty nice car. The 550 Spyder was a total blast to drive, 1100 lbs made for great power to weight ratio but you either cooked or froze in the car with no roof/windows or vent/heat. The Lotus Europa was great but fragile as it only weighted 1500 lbs. Loved the Pantera but that was back in the day and it was a pain to deal with the overheating problem and then there was the Italian build quality and wiring issues. I feel that the Boxster is a modern itineration of the 914 and 550 Spyder and great value for the money plus all of the modern niceties like A/C, cruise control, and all the other power goodies.

dghii 07-27-2015 07:06 PM

I wouldn't own the Boxster(s) that I've owned if it wasn't for the pure enjoyment of my 1975 x 1/9 that I purchased in 1977 out of high school, or the 1976 x 1/9 I drove through the last three years of college.

I also purchased a slightly used 1985 MR2 (2,000 miles on ODO) in early 1986 after waiting unsucessful, for the New MR2 I'd ordered to be delivered.

I still look at old X1/9's Spiders etc.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:46 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2025 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Pelican Parts Website