Wow, three wonderful choices. I could close my eyes, pick one randomly, and be thrilled with the decision.
The 911 has been my dream car since I was 2 years old, so I would have been tempted to go with that, but after almost 5,000 miles in my 987, I have to say that the handling, better visibilty, and same interior might actually make trading up to a stripper 911 a tough sell. The power of my 987 non-S is actually adequate for me. The only thing I would like more would be a C4S what with this being New Jersey and all, but I am looking forward to see how my Box will do with the snow tires I just bought.