Has anyone compared BMW M Roadster to the Boxster S?

[Rowag]

If I was buying, I'd go with the Boxster S. It's got plenty of power for me, and I love incredible-handling cars.

You may want to try a used M3 convertible, as well. Though as Lux pointed out, the steering feel in the E46 (the current chassis) M3 is horrible. But there's LOTS of power there and even though the steering rack is crap there are still some redeeming factors in the handling department.

I'm not certain if a lease would be a consideration, but if it is and you could use the practicality of 4 seats you may want to look into a 330ci convertible with the Performance Package (code named "ZHP"). That package includes a short shifter, different suspension setup, different cams/intake/exhaust, a shorter final drive, alcantara seats, alcantara steering wheel (leather now on later '05s but you can get it swapped), different exterior trim (bumpers, side flares), and different wheels. The car's fairly quick (235hp, 0-60 in 5.6, qtr mile low 14's @ 98mph), and handling is fantastic. There were some incredible lease specials for the past few months on the 330ci coupes as BMW needed to keep cash flow up for the launch of the new 3-series sedans this year. There might be similar deals on convertibles.

If you don't have a need/use for the 4 seats, though, buy the S or the M-roadster and enjoy. I agree with you on the "you always want more power" thing. That's why I'd buy the Boxster.

Originally Posted by Push

Which one would you choose?