Audi A4, Mercedes CLK, or BMW 328i?

[Lordblood]

Yes, this has nothing to do with a Boxster, but I wanted some opinions because my sister just got a job and now needs a car to get there.

She's looking for a used, 18-24k region. She said since she already can drive my Boxster, she isn't interested in a convertible or 2 seater. So we narrowed it down to those three.

I like the BMW best because it's the remodeled version, therefore has more standard equipment such as an AUX port which is pretty important as my sister lives in her Ipod. That plus I hear the 3 series is quite a nice car to drive.

Just wanted to know what you would go for and why. The A4 is going to be the last generation, which I hear has nasty electrical problems. Not sure on that though. As for the CLK, I think it's a nice car but my sister doesn't like the interior too much (she doesn't look wood apparently).

[Jeph]

In that price range, why a 328 over a 330? And it's probably over the top, but she could even get an M3 in that price range.

She could easily have this for 18k (330i)

[Lordblood]

Originally Posted by Jeph

In that price range, why a 328 over a 330? And it's probably over the top, but she could even get an M3 in that price range.

She could easily have this for 18k (330i)

I don't think the engine is her priority. The 328 is cheaper and she will be just as happy with it.

Now I'd get an M3 over those, but this isn't my money.

Also, did that generation of 3 series come with Ipod integration? At least an AUX port? I think that's the biggest pull for getting a new generation 3 series, my sister isn't even that happy with BMW anyway in terms of how it looks.

[gschotland]

Big thumbs up on the '06 325i / '07 328i. My 77 yr old father has an '07 328xi "sportwagon" and absolutely loves it. I've driven it many times and have often thought to myself, "This car would be perfect if it had stick." He regularly gets 22-23 mpg in everyday driving - not driving like a Grandpa, although he is one - and up to 29 highway. It's a great balance of sportiness and economy and a phenomenal value. You really can't go wrong.

My brother bought a 30k mile '06 330xi sedan last fall after selling me his '02 Boxster S (wife said the Box must go). After driving the 330 many times, I don't think the ~$3k price premium over the 325/328 is worth it; the added power just isn't that noticeable. A well optioned 325/328 should have everything you need.

Of the cars you mentioned only the 3 series is on Consumer Reports recommended list for reliability, if that matters to your sister.

[Brucelee]

I recommend some form of warranty on all of these cars. Each has had persistent issues, BMW and Audi with Auto trans and Mercedes with electrical in general.

Gotta love the 328i though. I am looking for a manual trans E46 as we speak.

Good luck.

[blue2000s]

Why a German car? She'll have a more trouble-free experience with a Toyota or Honda and in that price range, a newer model as well. I'm even reading really good things about the Fusion and Malibu, which could be purchased new in that price range.

[Lordblood]

I think we are sticking to the A4. My sister likes how it looks, and we have driven it when I sent my Box to the stealership for a repair.

As for Ipod integration, she is planning to get one of those FM converter things that transmits an FM signal to your radio. It'll be good enough for her liking.

[urban_legend]

I have both and all I can say about the A6 twin turbo with quatro...is more parts, more problems. It is a nice car but go with an extended warranty.