Hey Boxster Bob !
I think the best way to help you make up your mind is to drive the Boxster. I think your definition of razor sharp handling will take on a new meaning after spending some time in the Porsche. I just bought an identical car .... 2000 S, 26K miles and it is really an amazing car. Mine has a few minor creaks over bumpy pavement but even so, it feels like it is carved out of a solid block of steel. It feels much like a slightly refined go cart.
Yeah, the RMS thing sucks. You should probably take the car to a dealer and have them inspect it.
A Honda S2000 is another great car you might consider..... and probably better as far as build quality and tightness goes, but performance wise, the Porsche S is so much better balanced and will out run the Honda all day long........ plus, on looks alone, the Porsche wins hands down.
Anyway,the Boxster is a blast to drive and with the top down, it's the closest you'll come to a motorcycle experience.
