[rick3000]

I would avoid all seasons, they just aren't very good at anything. For most people a good set of max/high/ultra performance summer tires is probably best. If you expect to drive in temperatures below 40° F, especially if there is rain or snow I would highly recommend getting a dedicated set of winter tires.

I am currently running your #2 choice, the BFGoodrich g-Force Comp-2's. I am no tire expert, but I like them, they are responsive, grip well, and so far no issues.