[Giller]

I'll take a slightly smaller tire for better road smoothness any day - then again, I'm not a performance driver who's pushing the car to it's limits.

Also depends on the type of roads you have. They aren't the nicest up here with our winters - so like some extra rubber on there.

As for the wheels below - if I had to choose, I would go with the fronts. Not a fan of the narrow spokes on the back.