I have to say I like the look of these wheels a lot more on your car with the black finish.
One idea that just came to me would be to leave the lip grey/silver or even getting it refinished with a polished metal lip with the center black. It would come across as a more modern take on the Fuch wheel.
Sort of like this without the silver on the center spokes:
Something closer to this but with the more modern lines of the cayman wheels:
