It's been a decent scratch and chip fix on my Bimmer, but not perfect by any means.
Jfro, $550 to respray a front bumper when it's been removed from the car is 2-3x more than you'd have to pay here in Houston. I do hope they gold plated the thing for you.
I've got touch up paint from Porsche for the boxster and I'll use that until I can afford to have the whole car resprayed ... and 3M film installed.
I wish I could afford to have my car wrapped like the Ferrari boys do