Quote:
	
	
		| 
					Originally Posted by JFP in PA
					
				 How did they test the battery?  If all they did was run a voltage test, they wasted your time.  The only true test of a battery is to fully charge it, let it sit and cool, and then load test it.  You cannot run a proper load test on a partially discharged battery.  A load test is a "pass/fail" test, the battery can either deliver the amps or not.
 From what you describe, it has all the earmarks of a dying battery.......
 | 
	
 
Or test the electrolyte for specific gravity.  Sounds like a battery issue to me too.  Basically, if the battery is 3 yrs. old or older, it is always suspect.
Lead Acid batteries also incrementally lose their ability to hold a charge with each discharge.  After about 5 discharges, it's usually shot.  This would be exascerbated in cold weather too.
Bottom line, quit p*ssing around and if it's 3 yrs. old, replace it and be done with it.  Last thing you want in a Chicago winter is to be stranded in the cold by a so-so battery.
 
