[drburton]

I assume the Carrera S is the coupe? I think this is really a personal decision related to what works best for you. But since you asked for an opinion, I'll give mine. The Carrera for sure, here is why:

- Backseat, this is a huge benefit for me, could tote the kids with
- Power - 355HP would be sweet
- Love the 911, always have
- Coupe seems for flexible to me, could drive it year round

I guess the big question is can you do without a convertible. I say go for the 911 if it is in good condition.