So stick or TIP?
How long are you going to keep it? Is resale important? And how does it influence the choice of color? (Resale differs by up to 20%!!!)
Are you willing to travel for the car (its still cold up north and deals are better when the streets are covered with white stuff that isn't sand)?
I've had 2 Boxsters. A '99 with 201HP and a '01 with 245. I see no difference in the fun factor.
If I were buying today, I'd definitely buy a base 987 over a 986 just for the hundreds of little improvements they made between models.
Some points of advice...drive several...don't fall in love with one (there are hundreds for sale today)..and get a PPI.
Some additional thoughts
here
would apply to buying either.
Get to work, you've missed months of fun since your initial posting.