De-snorkeling 986: Yes or no?
Is there any reason NOT to de-snorkel a '99 Boxster? I guess the only thing that would concern me is debris or water getting down into the engine. Any opinions on this?
|
For a short period I parked my car on a very busy Los Angeles street. I let it sit for about a week once and the car had serious problems starting. I'm 99 percent certain that dust filled the intake system and covered the MAF. When you desnorkle it does all more dust in there. But so far, there isn't a downside that I see. I removed MAF, cleaned, and was back on my way in ten minutes.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
When I say busy street, I mean very busy. There way a drag race at least hourly all night long, Thousands of cars a day braking intensely from long uninterrupted stretch. I saw people travelling over 100 mph every day on that road. So yes, dust can get past all that stuff. I offer firsthand experience, this is exactly what happened. There's zero doubt in my mind. |
Quote:
And, it has absolutely Nothing to do with whether the car is snorkeled or DE-snorkeled. Sent from my SM-G970U using Tapatalk |
Related to OP's inquiry, what is intended to be the point of the snorkel? Agreed that the lack of the snorkel should have no impact on getting dust/debris to the MAF; the filter should have prevented that. @junkley, is it possible that your air filter wasn't positioned correctly or that there's a leak that's allowing air past the filter?
No snark intended on this end. Just trying to 1) learn why Porsche installed the snorkel if it's extraneous, and 2) hopefully help spot why @junkley had dirt in the MAF. |
Quote:
It is possible that something was out of whack but I'm 99 percent sure the added dust was the problem. |
Quote:
To get water into the engine from the intake on the side of the car, you would need to direct a high pressure blast straight into- and- back, in essence TRYING to get water into the motor. There is no harm in removing it. But those who tell you they felt it increase power have succumbed to placebo. ;-) |
De-snorkeling will give you increased intake noise.
And that's all it will do. It's not going to add power. And its not going to allow any extra dirt or dust into your system. |
Quote:
Some even argue that "Perception IS reality" but that would spiral us into a political argument...:D:D |
Based on my experience, the car does sound a lot cooler with the snorkel removed. Probably no power increase, but it sounds like it's making more power!
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Sent from my SM-G970U using Tapatalk |
Quote:
And, it's pretty easy. No brainer, eh? |
Ditto...Love that sound !!
|
Looks like I have this weekend's project figured out.
|
Is it hard to resnorkle if you're not happy with the results or does removal destroy the parts
|
Quote:
I stuck a broom handle in mine shoved to the left and right and popped it out in seconds. It can be snapped back in place in about the same amount of time. Takes longer to remove the grill over the intake opening then it does to remove or replace the snorkel. |
Quote:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5dyh1jgvTDY Good luck! |
Throttle response with a 74mm TB sufers without the snork
|
All times are GMT -8. The time now is 01:51 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2024 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Pelican Parts Website