986 Forum - The Community for Porsche Boxster & Cayman Owners

986 Forum - The Community for Porsche Boxster & Cayman Owners (http://986forum.com/forums/)
-   Performance and Technical Chat (http://986forum.com/forums/performance-technical-chat/)
-   -   Best Headers for 2002 3.6L in Boxster (http://986forum.com/forums/performance-technical-chat/17767-best-headers-2002-3-6l-boxster.html)

m2speed 08-02-2008 02:39 PM

Best Headers for 2002 3.6L in Boxster
 
What is the best header that will fit in a 2002 Boxster S with a 2002 996 3.6L? performance is the goal and past emissions. Is the SCargo the best? money is also a factor too.

Adam 08-02-2008 04:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by m2speed
What is the best header that will fit in a 2002 Boxster S with a 2002 996 3.6L? performance is the goal and past emissions. Is the SCargo the best? money is also a factor too.

Fabspeed headers are the best.

easyc 08-03-2008 12:12 AM

Thats a difficult question... ideally since you are running .4 more liters, you would want headers bigger than those made for a 3.2 or 2.7... but 996 headers do not fit under a Boxster... so just find the biggest you can.... BUT you want to pass emissions... thats a whole other can of worms which would start with does your state check emissions? or do they rely on the OBC? do you want to run your secondary cats? etc etc... that answer can be searched on here...

m2speed 08-03-2008 12:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by easyc
Thats a difficult question... ideally since you are running .4 more liters, you would want headers bigger than those made for a 3.2 or 2.7... but 996 headers do not fit under a Boxster... so just find the biggest you can.... BUT you want to pass emissions... thats a whole other can of worms which would start with does your state check emissions? or do they rely on the OBC? do you want to run your secondary cats? etc etc... that answer can be searched on here...

Well you made a very good point about missions. In Austin they only check for codes on OBD II cars. Older ones they do the sniff test. I think that is correct anyway. If so I could forgo the secondary cats and use thoses bypass sensor adaptors too keep the trouble codes away.

tholyoak 08-03-2008 09:18 AM

Any header made for a 986 is too small for the 3.6. With the 3.6 Porsche enlarged the exhaust ports size significantly. Previously the 996 3.4 and 986 engines used the same size exhaust ports so using a set of 3.2S performance headers was a good solution. Not so with the 3.6 and 3.8 swaps. This obviously ignores the primary size and length, which are also wrong for a 3.6 on the 986 based headers.

-Todd

m2speed 08-03-2008 12:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tholyoak
Any header made for a 986 is too small for the 3.6. With the 3.6 Porsche enlarged the exhaust ports size significantly. Previously the 996 3.4 and 986 engines used the same size exhaust ports so using a set of 3.2S performance headers was a good solution. Not so with the 3.6 and 3.8 swaps. This obviously ignores the primary size and length, which are also wrong for a 3.6 on the 986 based headers.

-Todd

So what is the solution? Does anyone make a good header for the 3.6L to 3.8L in a 986?

easyc 08-03-2008 03:03 PM

Im using a set of the Maxspeed/ Schnell type... they had the largest diameter I could find plus O2 bungs.... until I get a custom set made OR crack them they will have to do

tholyoak 08-03-2008 04:11 PM

Top is gasket for a 3.6L engine, bottom is 986 Boxster/996 3.4 gasket. As you can see, you aren't doing your engine any favours by running 986 headers on a 3.6L engine.

http://home.everestkc.net/tholyoak/DSCN1267.jpg
-Todd

m2speed 08-03-2008 04:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tholyoak
Top is gasket for a 3.6L engine, bottom is 986 Boxster/996 3.4 gasket. As you can see, you aren't doing your engine any favours by running 986 headers on a 3.6L engine.

http://home.everestkc.net/tholyoak/DSCN1267.jpg
-Todd

What header are you using? Maxspeed has one with sports cats and one without that they state are a good fit for the 3.6L conversions.

silver arrow 08-03-2008 04:43 PM

Seems like custum headers would be the expensive and right choice.

Cloudsurfer 08-03-2008 05:36 PM

Todd is running some top secret creation of his own ;)

The Maxspeed catted headers look like they'd flow horribly to me, not to mention I can't imagine that they were designed for the larger ports of a 3.6.

Patrick

m2speed 08-04-2008 04:25 AM

Todd or whoever knows,

What is the width and height of the ports? trying to figure the size primary really needed for the 3.6L header. I have a tig welder and might have to do the custom thing. My 3.6L is coming UPS freight on Tuesday or Wednesday from Houston to Austin.

My 2002 3.2L engine will be for sell soon. 43K miles and runs perfect.

Jeff

tholyoak 08-04-2008 06:26 AM

I agree with Patrick, those catted maxspeed headers look like not much thought went into designing them.

No need to go custom, come on guys do I have to spoon feed you everything ;)

I have stated, you can't use 986 headers... what comes after 986... that's right headers designed for the 987, in particular the 3.4 in the Boxster or Cayman S. They have the right size ports and the primaries and collectors are pretty much the right sizes. The modifications needed to get them to work are minimal to none depending on the muffler and header choice.

Here is the Fabspeed on my car now, I also have a set of B&B. I am probably selling the B&B set if anyone is interested.

http://home.everestkc.net/tholyoak/DSCN1268.jpg

-Todd

m2speed 08-04-2008 08:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tholyoak

Here is the Fabspeed on my car now, I also have a set of B&B. I am probably selling the B&B set if anyone is interested.

http://home.everestkc.net/tholyoak/DSCN1268.jpg

-Todd

What are the specs on the B & B headers and do they have cats? What price are you wanting? Also how do the specs of the Fabspeed compare to that of the B & B? Do you have pics of the B & B?
Jeff

Kirk 08-04-2008 12:35 PM

I think Todd is going to have the best advice hear seeing as he's actually done this engine swap. Thank you Todd for giving us the info, it is appreciated!

I'm just going to throw in my 2 cents... You might want to give Instant G a call. They specifically make an aftermarket exhaust system for the 3.4 L Boxster conversion. From their website it sounds like it's pretty oversized for the application, so it may work well for a 3.6L too. I'd ask them. Plus they may be willing to make something to fit your car as they appear to be a small, custom order type of operation. I think their 3.4L system is about $3,000 complete (headers, mid-pipes, and muffler), so it's not cheap, but the quality and design appear to be top notch.

Here's their main site:

http://www.instant-g.com/

And specific info about the 3.4L Boxster exhaust system:

http://www.instant-g.com/Products/Exhausts/Box34/index.html

Kirk

m2speed 08-04-2008 01:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kirk
I think Todd is going to have the best advice hear seeing as he's actually done this engine swap. Thank you Todd for giving us the info, it is appreciated!

I'm just going to throw in my 2 cents... You might want to give Instant G a call. They specifically make an aftermarket exhaust system for the 3.4 L Boxster conversion. From their website it sounds like it's pretty oversized for the application, so it may work well for a 3.6L too. I'd ask them. Plus they may be willing to make something to fit your car as they appear to be a small, custom order type of operation. I think their 3.4L system is about $3,000 complete (headers, mid-pipes, and muffler), so it's not cheap, but the quality and design appear to be top notch.

Kirk

Looks good but not crazy about that flat triangle collector.

I called B & B about an hour ago. I asked about the Cayman header they sell as fitting the 986 w/ 3.6L He didn’t think it would fit with out cutting it up and re-fabbing it. He thought that a custom set from scratch was the right answer if you have the equipment to do it. I do so I think I’m going that route.

He gave me the place where they buy their components to build stainless mandrel bent headers. They sell collectors, flanges and all the stuff to build a really quality set of headers. I would like the best size primary diameter and length to have it work as good as possible. They have many different high quality 3 into 1 collectors too. They sell 321 and 304 stainless parts. I have a mill, band saws, drill press, tig welder, torches, and other metal working tools to get it done.
Jeff

tholyoak 08-04-2008 01:31 PM

I can't believe people. Go and believe someone who hasn't done it. Just because I have put a full Cayman B&B setup on one car and a combination of cayman Fabspeed and Supersprint on another, I guess it can't be done without a bunch of fab'ing. Please stop wasting my time.

Todd

m2speed 08-04-2008 01:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tholyoak
I can't believe people. Go and believe someone who hasn't done it. Just because I have put a full Cayman B&B setup on one car and a combination of cayman Fabspeed and Supersprint on another, I guess it can't be done without a bunch of fab'ing. Please stop wasting my time.

Todd

Look Todd I thank you for your input. You did say you have put the cayman header on your car. I called B&B because IM VERY INTERESTED and not wanting to wast anybodies time. Yours eighter so I called them directly. PM me your number and I will call you too. Really not wanting to piss people off. I need input and help and that why I'm on here.
Sincerely,
Jeff

m2speed 08-05-2008 06:08 AM

I found an interesting header for the Boxster 987 / Cayman at Design911. It looks pretty well designed and would flow well and it has cats. Not a lot of specs on it yet and the price is high. This header like a lot of them are more of a true exhaust manifold than a header with very short primary pipes, not really taking the need for the correct length and diameter into consideration for all out engine performance.

http://www.design911.co.uk/index.htm?Region=US


I really like the B&B header and a person could mount a set of cats somewhere else down stream. The folks at B&B were interested in quality and performance both. They did not try to up-sale me on anything, but tried to steer me in the direction that they thought the best for what I was trying to do. I really appreciate a company like that. Without hesitation they told me where they buy the parts that they use and I could do it myself and a more of a one-off cost effective way.

m2speed 08-05-2008 06:17 AM

Here is the link to Bill Boat Performance Exhaust (B&B) I couldn't copy there pic of the Cayman header and post it here or at least I didn't know how too.

http://www.bbexhaust.com/car/cayman/

tholyoak 08-05-2008 06:25 AM

I guess I am feeling a little more charitable today so I will give you some more details against my better judgement. ;)

You are making the same, possibly incorrect assumptions about header design as I made. I too liked the longer primary design of B&B headers and assumed headers like the Fabspeed were made with short primaries to accommodate cats even in their headers without cats.

Upon comparison the B&B fabrication is not up to the standards of Fabspeed, the B&B use a stepped primary, which is far cheaper to manufacture and their collector design is not as neat of a piece as the one peice 'F1' merge collector on the Fabspeed.

I have dyno tested the B&B and will dyno the Fabspeed that is now on the car this weekend as long as the dyno shop is open. The butt dyno says there is no appreciable difference between the two header designs, simply they have went about the process in two different ways, but we'll see what the dyno says.

A crappy cell pic of the B&B headers

http://home.everestkc.net/tholyoak/0805080701.jpg
-Todd

m2speed 08-05-2008 01:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tholyoak
I guess I am feeling a little more charitable today so I will give you some more details against my better judgement. ;)

You are making the same, possibly incorrect assumptions about header design as I made. I too liked the longer primary design of B&B headers and assumed headers like the Fabspeed were made with short primaries to accommodate cats even in their headers without cats.

Upon comparison the B&B fabrication is not up to the standards of Fabspeed, the B&B use a stepped primary, which is far cheaper to manufacture and their collector design is not as neat of a piece as the one peice 'F1' merge collector on the Fabspeed.

I have dyno tested the B&B and will dyno the Fabspeed that is now on the car this weekend as long as the dyno shop is open. The butt dyno says there is no appreciable difference between the two header designs, simply they have went about the process in two different ways, but we'll see what the dyno says.

-Todd

Thanks Todd for your experience and knowledge, I have to run UPS called and the engine is in and I have to go pick it up there. :dance:

Ike 08-05-2008 02:27 PM

3.6L Header Option
 
Dude,

I have these RUF headers on my 3.6L x51 powerplant in a 986 '03 S. I have no problems with the set up at all. It runs like a raped ape!

If you want more info on their headers and applications, call Wayne Corely at 888-783-6872.

Hasta,
Ike

m2speed 08-05-2008 07:53 PM

It Here!
 
I picked up my engine today. '02 3.6L 911 Carrera with 28K miles. Missing many piece that I had thought would come with it inclueding the upper intake. I will call in the morning to try and get it. I got tied up with the poison sisters tonight to really worry about it. Hope you can understand the priorities.

m2speed 08-05-2008 08:06 PM

3.6L Engine
 
here's the pic of the 2002 3.6L 911 Whats missing?

Cloudsurfer 08-05-2008 09:22 PM

Missing quite a bit.....but looks to be a VERY clean block.

Patrick

tholyoak 08-06-2008 04:23 AM

A) Ruf will not sell you individual components from their swaps. They will only provide complete conversions, or replacement parts for a previous conversion

B) Those simply look like X51 headers that have been modified to work flipped around on the 996. If you are a good fabricator and have the necessary tools this is always an option.

-Todd

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ike
Dude,

I have these RUF headers on my 3.6L x51 powerplant in a 986 '03 S. I have no problems with the set up at all. It runs like a raped ape!

If you want more info on their headers and applications, call Wayne Corely at 888-783-6872.

Hasta,
Ike


JP-s-in st. louis 08-06-2008 08:25 AM

Todd, Easy

I need help quick! How did you lower the motor was there a different motor mount you used or??? I need one ASAP!

:cheers:

tholyoak 08-06-2008 09:37 AM

Did you read the pdf over at renntech? Fitting the 3.6 is the same as fitting a 3.4. You simply use longer bolts and a spacer. I fabricate my spacer out of aluminum stock.
A lot of people on this board seem to think this is all new. Go over to renntech and do a search. You will quickly find that I have answered these questions over and over again.

-Todd

JP-s-in st. louis 08-06-2008 10:58 AM

Sorry Todd but I did the search under 3.6 and just now found it under the 3.4. I do appreciate all the assistance with this and that PDF file will come in to good use. You may want to add that link to your sig for any other future people who do a search. "my 3.4 into 986 install" It may save time and of course your frustration.


Thanks again
Josh
:cheers:


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 03:12 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2024 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Pelican Parts Website