986 Forum - The Community for Porsche Boxster & Cayman Owners

986 Forum - The Community for Porsche Boxster & Cayman Owners (http://986forum.com/forums/)
-   Boxster General Discussions (http://986forum.com/forums/boxster-general-discussions/)
-   -   Small foam pieces blowing from vents (http://986forum.com/forums/boxster-general-discussions/67109-small-foam-pieces-blowing-vents.html)

Rob175 06-15-2017 06:51 AM

Small foam pieces blowing from vents
 
My (otherwise perfect) 1998 Boxster with 80M miles occasionally blows out small pieces of dark grey foam from the vents (dashboard and floor). Its not an everyday occurrence but still it happens from time to time. The heat and the AC both work fine and the fan blows perfectly at all levels. The pieces range in size from pea size to nickel size with the larger size sometimes getting stuck in the vent louvers so I remove those with a tweezers. I'm wondering if on a car this age it's not uncommon or if it's something that I should have looked at?? Everything else is fine.

RedTele58 06-15-2017 07:06 AM

It's pretty common.
Read this: http://986forum.com/forums/performance-technical-chat/42802-interior-vent-debris.html

Rob175 06-16-2017 04:42 AM

Thanks.....looks like a BIG job if a DIY....and a costly job if you hire a shop. I think I'll just monitor it. I seldom drive my Boxster in the winter except to exercise the engine for 15 minutes on ice/snow free sunny days. So most all of my driving is in the summer with the top down and the AC off......... I think I'll let this go for now and just drive the car. I suppose its a good sign that the pieces blow out rather than collect in the vent system.

Luckyed 06-16-2017 10:44 AM

My 2001 started puking foam a year and a half ago and now I only see a small piece every now and then. I expect there is not too much of it left in there.

Besides, I don't think I have turned on the heater since I bought the car 3 years ago........lol

78F350 06-16-2017 01:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob175 (Post 540913)
Thanks.....looks like a BIG job if a DIY....and a costly job if you hire a shop. I think I'll just monitor it. I seldom drive my Boxster in the winter except to exercise the engine for 15 minutes on ice/snow free sunny days. So most all of my driving is in the summer with the top down and the AC off......... I think I'll let this go for now and just drive the car. I suppose its a good sign that the pieces blow out rather than collect in the vent system.

It can be a big job, or a fairly quick and easy job. Did you read the whole thread that Redtele58 linked? This is from the 38th post:
Quote:

  1. I ended up pulling out the console, which had already been modified for a 2 DIN head unit.
  2. Cut the duct so I could peel it down out of the way and temporarily taped it.
  3. My foam was COMPLETELY gone, otherwise I would have cleaned the flaps.
  4. Covered the flaps with a heavy duct tape that has a long lasting, thick adhesive.
  5. Tested the operation to make sure nothing was blocked and the tape was secure.
  6. Put it back together and used the same tape to seal the duct.
Relatively quick and painless. YMMV depending on your center console configuration.:dance:
http://986forum.com/forums/uploads02...1478054876.jpg

http://986forum.com/forums/uploads02...1478054894.jpg

http://986forum.com/forums/uploads02...1478054906.jpg

http://986forum.com/forums/uploads02...1478054931.jpg

ExplorerLyon 06-16-2017 01:18 PM

Has anyone else used the method show in the post above? I asked in the other thread and got no response. Is this now the best and easiest method.

78F350 06-16-2017 01:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ExplorerLyon (Post 540969)
Has anyone else used the method show in the post above? I asked in the other thread and got no response. Is this now the best and easiest method.

I don't know how many others have done it, but mine is still working flawlessly.

patssle 06-16-2017 03:20 PM

Does that cover the entire flapper? I thought it's longer than that? That method definitely beats every other method if it gets the job done! Mine has also spit out all the foam. A/C is fine but heat doesn't get too hot. Thankful for seat warmers.

Boxstard 06-16-2017 04:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by patssle (Post 540977)
Does that cover the entire flapper? I thought it's longer than that? That method definitely beats every other method if it gets the job done! Mine has also spit out all the foam. A/C is fine but heat doesn't get too hot. Thankful for seat warmers.

With the way you cut it up open, can you get to the bottom of two flaps to tape up holes all the way down? From pics it looks as if only top half of those flaps are exposed and accessible.

78F350 06-16-2017 04:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Boxstard (Post 540980)
With the way you cut it up open, can you get to the bottom of two flaps to tape up holes all the way down? From pics it looks as if only top half of those flaps are exposed and accessible.

The whole flap is accessible (both flaps). Small hands or a tool make it easier.
Quote:

Originally Posted by 78F350 (Post 515267)
I used strips of tape that were between two and four inches long. At first I tried poking them in with a trim tool, but using my hand worked best. With the flaps in the resting position, it was difficult, but doable. I think that the best access was with the AC running and the fan on low. I poked my camera in for this shot, then put on one more piece of tape to caver a gap:
http://986forum.com/forums/uploads02...1478095838.jpg

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vidyashankara (Post 538832)
78F350: Freaking awesome!

I just did this. When I opened up the console and all my foam was gone. I used a standard cutting blade to make the cuts on the vent. I used masking tape to tape up the holes. Took me totally 15 minutes in total. It was very easy to tape the vents with my hands. I did not need to use any tools

Thanks for the innovative process :)


Boxstard 06-18-2017 05:11 AM

Oh wow, great access and I got small hands! Is this pic taken from the center stereo/ climate control opening, though? From other pics it did look like that only top half of flaps were expose, maybe the cut section was not peeled back all the way down?

seningen 06-18-2017 03:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by patssle (Post 540977)
Does that cover the entire flapper? I thought it's longer than that? That method definitely beats every other method if it gets the job done! Mine has also spit out all the foam. A/C is fine but heat doesn't get too hot. Thankful for seat warmers.

I was like -- ohh, no heat -- then I saw your Houston tag on your profile --
seriously :-)

Melting in Austin,

Mike

78F350 06-18-2017 06:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Boxstard (Post 541138)
...From other pics it did look like that only top half of flaps were expose, maybe the cut section was not peeled back all the way down?

The cut section was not peeled as far is it can be. All of both flaps can be reached, but seeing them completely may be difficult due to the angle and depth behind the dashboard.

Back to my original posts in the other thread, here's a pic that I posted showing the back side of the duct that you are cutting for access.
http://986forum.com/forums/uploads02...1478054133.jpg

Or perhaps read the entire post where I introduced the concept:
http://986forum.com/forums/515250-post37.html

particlewave 06-19-2017 02:20 AM

3 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by ExplorerLyon (Post 540969)
Has anyone else used the method show in the post above? I asked in the other thread and got no response. Is this now the best and easiest method.

Yes. I split the upper duct at the seam, though.
It was a pain getting all of the old foam and its backing material out, and getting the flaps covered, but a lot easier and more thorough than the other method that requires removal of the heater core and does not address the other flap.

Boxstard 06-19-2017 05:44 AM

Okay thanks for additional pictures for further clarity. This is going to be my project in near future.

I'm thinking of using aluminum duct tape but any potential issues? I wonder why they used foam to plug those holes in the first place that can not be air-tight, just for muffling and noise dampening? Will blocking holes with solid tape create hissing noise?

Alfieg23 06-19-2017 08:18 AM

Vent foam
 
I have almost eliminated this issue by doing the following.

1. Close all A/C vents
2. Turn A/C on HIGH with air direction straight out (no upper or lower stream)
3. Turn vacuum cleaner on and place nozzle brush against each vent, opening only that vent.
4. Close vent and repeat with other dash vents.

The air pressure forced the foam pieces to come out of each vent. I did this over a year ago and have had only a couple of small pieces come out since. I may need to do this again at some point, depending on how much foam was left behind and when it deteriorates.

particlewave 06-19-2017 03:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alfieg23 (Post 541265)
I have almost eliminated this issue by doing the following.

1. Close all A/C vents
2. Turn A/C on HIGH with air direction straight out (no upper or lower stream)
3. Turn vacuum cleaner on and place nozzle brush against each vent, opening only that vent.
4. Close vent and repeat with other dash vents.

The air pressure forced the foam pieces to come out of each vent. I did this over a year ago and have had only a couple of small pieces come out since. I may need to do this again at some point, depending on how much foam was left behind and when it deteriorates.

The problem with this is that the flaps have holes.

Gelbster 06-21-2017 07:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alfieg23 (Post 541265)
I have almost eliminated this issue by doing the following.

1. Close all A/C vents
2. Turn A/C on HIGH with air direction straight out (no upper or lower stream)
3. Turn vacuum cleaner on and place nozzle brush against each vent, opening only that vent.
4. Close vent and repeat with other dash vents.

The air pressure forced the foam pieces to come out of each vent. I did this over a year ago and have had only a couple of small pieces come out since. I may need to do this again at some point, depending on how much foam was left behind and when it deteriorates.

What pity this does not work well ! Particlewave explained why .
But suppose you install a simple,direct,hand operated valve on the hot coolant inlet hose to the heater core .That would prevent warming of the a/c air. Anyone tried this? Where is the best location for such a valve ? It should be simple to just use a Home Depot valve with a hose barb at each side.
This one even has some bling ! Would tke 20 mins max to do
SharkBite 3/8 in. Chrome-Plated Brass PEX Barb Quarter-Turn Straight Stop-23382LF - The Home Depot
or search AmaZon for "3/8 barb x barb valve" Maybe 1/2" is the correct size? It is easy to just rummage at H.D.Plumbing Dept with a sample of your heater hose in hand and get separate barb fittings to connect to a standard,straight brass valve.

If this would work it would be a good interim fix because the procedures described above would take many hours of careful work.
While you are in there jobs? - the horn ring fix !
Feel free to improve on the suggestion

Alfieg23 06-21-2017 02:02 PM

Vent foam
 
The process I suggested is not to be done while driving so it does not affect the air temperature while driving. I did it to see if it resolved the frequent pieces of foam from shooting out the vents. I open each vent with the A/C on full blast for maybe 5 minutes each with the vacuum on and its nozzle brush flush against the open vent (and the other vents closed). After I repeat this with each vent, I then open all the vents and resume using the A/C as usual. I have only had a couple of small pieces of foam come out in over a year which I think is pretty good.

particlewave 06-21-2017 02:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alfieg23 (Post 541613)
The process I suggested is not to be done while driving so it does not affect the air temperature while driving. I did it to see if it resolved the frequent pieces of foam from shooting out the vents. I open each vent with the A/C on full blast for maybe 5 minutes each with the vacuum on and its nozzle brush flush against the open vent (and the other vents closed). After I repeat this with each vent, I then open all the vents and resume using the A/C as usual. I have only had a couple of small pieces of foam come out in over a year which I think is pretty good.

I think you missed the point. :)
Without installing new material on the flaps to replace the lost foam, the diverter flaps won't divert correctly.
Your AC will be blowing over the hot heater core, at least partially, making the AC not as cold as it could/should be.

Gelbster 06-21-2017 03:32 PM

More on the quick-fix or work-around involving the heater valve.
The heater valve is accessible via the passenger side rear wheel arch (remove wheel).
The Heater valve may also be accessible from above via the engine compartment(remove cover and grope).
Here is a kind guy who posted a video showing replacement of the valve so it gives all the grimy details:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SC198GztmvE
The important part of the video is where he shows how the 2 halves of the plastic valve just fall apart and dump coolant !
Please note the stock plastic heater valve tends to separate where it is glued together, then leaks . That could cause a catastrophic engine failure.
Napa sell a vacuum-operated part that looks similar to the OEM part and is mainly metal with a better crimp:
BK 6601410.
But Four Seasons or Everco sell an all metal vacuum controlled heater control valve that may fit??? It is part # 74671. This valve also fits Audis + some 90's Fords according to Posts in other Forums. The Porsche 944/968 guys use it as an upgrade.
An alternative in all metal intended for 12mm i.d. heater hose is to search "Van Heater Control Valve Kit C3UZ18495A YG133 For FORD E & F SERIES BRONCO DODGE" Just rotate the lever to either block (summer)or allow(winter) coolant to reach the heater core.

To understand why this hack may be a delightfully easy suggestion , read this lengthy, difficult how to:
http://986forum.com/forums/performance-technical-chat/42802-interior-vent-debris-2.html#post323947
There are some useful links there posted by Mr.Stone.

Another detailed link of the full repair process.
https://www.scribd.com/document/212147792/986-Heater-Flap-Repair-Boxster-foam
Another from Forum Member Meir:
https://www.dropbox.com/s/hx9qr0t3jtkv6th/986%20Heater%20Flap%20Repair.pdf?dl=0

There is a simpler way(78F350 in post 9 below) to access the offending flaps in this link and also in this thread:http://986forum.com/forums/performance-technical-chat/42802-interior-vent-debris.html
The simpler system link does require cutting and this is clearly shown in the hi res photos.
You need this tape to do the job well: 3M Flue tape
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00004Z4DS

But whatever you do, replace the risky OEM part to avoid the leakage

78F350 06-21-2017 07:49 PM

Gelbster, anyone who can't follow the simple instructions I posted earlier in this thread for accessing and repairing the HVAC flaps behind the stereo unit probably shouldn't attempt to take their wheels off or look for heater valves. I can see potential for damage. Besides, why disable the unit when it is easier to repair?

Gelbster 06-21-2017 07:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 78F350 (Post 541645)
Gelbster, anyone who can't follow the simple instructions I posted earlier in this thread for accessing and repairing the HVAC flaps behind the stereo unit probably shouldn't attempt to take their wheels off or look for heater valves. I can see potential for damage. Besides, why disable the unit when it is easier to repair?

It isn't disabling it.It is a seasonal shut-off.Manually operated Was common on older cars .
At least replace the aging heater control valve?
The listed parts will operate with vacuum exactly like the original part and last longer,without the P-car tax:
"Napa sell a vacuum-operated part that looks similar to the OEM part and is mainly metal with a better crimp:
BK 6601410.
But Four Seasons or Everco sell an all metal vacuum controlled heater control valve that may fit??? It is part # 74671. This valve also fits Audis + some 90's Fords according to Posts in other Forums. The Porsche 944/968 guys use it as an upgrade
. "
The OEM part # is (but check!) 92857457303. It is $30. But it is all plastic and glued together.

particlewave 06-21-2017 08:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gelbster (Post 541646)
At least replace the aging heater control valve?

I'll have to have a look one of these days. ;)

Alfieg23 06-22-2017 05:40 AM

Sorry, particlewave, I did miss your point. I guess I have been fortunate. I have had my 986 for five years and up until I did the process I previously mentioned I had quite a bit of foam come out of my A/C vents. As such, it is quite possible that most of the original foam is no longer in place. Having said that, I have not noticed any drop-off in cooling from the A/C even during our scorching South Florida summers.

dghii 06-22-2017 08:06 AM

My foam is long gone. AC still works great but my heater is not as effective as it once was. Luckily, here in FL, heater is effective enough.

78F350 06-22-2017 10:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gelbster (Post 541646)
It isn't disabling it.It is a seasonal shut-off.Manually operated Was common on older cars .
At least replace the aging heater control valve?
The listed parts will operate with vacuum exactly like the original part and last longer,without the P-car tax:
"Napa sell a vacuum-operated part that looks similar to the OEM part and is mainly metal with a better crimp:
BK 6601410.
But Four Seasons or Everco sell an all metal vacuum controlled heater control valve that may fit??? It is part # 74671. This valve also fits Audis + some 90's Fords according to Posts in other Forums. The Porsche 944/968 guys use it as an upgrade
. "
The OEM part # is (but check!) 92857457303. It is $30. But it is all plastic and glued together.

I think that I understand your intent. I just don't see the need. I checked through PET and did some searching. I don't think that our cars (986s) have that valve. The circulation through the heater core is constant and not regulated. There is a similar vacuum controlled valve for the transmission cooler on the tiptronics, but nothing for the heater core.
Sure, you could put a manual valve in and operate it seasonally. That brings back memories of working in government buildings that had a date set to change from heat to AC and back regardless of the temperature. I did in fact have my 1978 F350 rigged for manually opening a flap under the hood to circulate through the heater core. My Boxsters all operate correctly via the climate control panel.

particlewave 06-22-2017 11:23 AM

Yeah, I definitely don't have that valve and the heater core is always hot.
I think 78F350 is correct. That valve appears to be for the tiptronic.

Thanks for the DIY, by the way. I never planned to do the repair through the heater core access hole because it did not address the other flap. With your method, I had it done in less than 2 hours and I'm now foam free! :D

Gelbster 06-22-2017 11:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by particlewave (Post 541689)
Yeah, I definitely don't have that valve and the heater core is always hot.
I think 78F350 is correct. That valve appears to be for the tiptronic.

Thanks guys. My sources show the Tip with 2 of these valves - 1 for the trans and one for the heater. I presumed the manual trans cars still have one for the heater.Why else is it labeled a "Heater Control Valve" ?:
Just search for ECS Meyle 92857457303.Sorry Pelican, your site search did not yield anything except for a 944.The Vertex site confirms it fits my 2001 Bxtr S 6 speed..
Another issue is that a Thread contributor(see 26 below) commented that the lack of foam seemed to have no effect on his a/c in Florida. That seems strange.
So maybe back to the original plan. Find an easily accessible spot to insert a seasonal valve on the input side of the heater core ?

particlewave 06-22-2017 11:40 AM

That is weird...maybe Porsche added one to all models in later years?
Or maybe I'm just missing something :)

ctimgo 07-17-2017 06:11 AM

Did you or anybody else try the cutoff valve for the heater core? If so how did it work? Thanks


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 07:44 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2025 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Pelican Parts Website