986 Forum - The Community for Porsche Boxster & Cayman Owners

986 Forum - The Community for Porsche Boxster & Cayman Owners (http://986forum.com/forums/)
-   Boxster General Discussions (http://986forum.com/forums/boxster-general-discussions/)
-   -   Another Stereo Question (http://986forum.com/forums/boxster-general-discussions/64430-another-stereo-question.html)

keeters 11-22-2016 10:37 AM

Another Stereo Question
 
Happy Thanksgiving,

I have a 2004 Porsche Boxster with the CD23 headset/amplifier. I want to add bluetooth for both calls and music. I have decided to purchase a CDR-220. I would also like to add an aftermarket amp (I already have upgraded speakers).

Can anyone tell me if what I want to accomplish is possible? Would it also be possible to power the speakers from the head unit itself?

If it is possible, what parts would I need to purchase.

Thank you in advance.

Pdwight 11-22-2016 02:12 PM

Hello, I installed a Pioneer head in my 01S about 6 months after I purchased it. I think I spent 85 bucks and of course it has bluetooth. I decided to add rear speakers to my unti about 4 months later. The pioneer was such an improvement on the OEM unit....but when I added the rear speakers and drove them directly from the pioneer head it was an incredible improvement. I plan on driving the front speakers directly from the head and bypassing the crappy OEM stuff completely....FWIW I am a 60 year old person who hates the "Thumping sound of stereos" just clean music. Also if your front speakers have not been replaced odds are they are in tatters and need replacing.

particlewave 11-22-2016 02:24 PM

You can't run speakers straight off of the OEM units. Without an amp, the sound output would be nil.

The OEM equipment is pure garbage (all of them, head units and amps). Don't bother.

Pdwight 11-22-2016 04:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by particlewave (Post 517433)
You can't run speakers straight off of the OEM units. Without an amp, the sound output would be nil.

The OEM equipment is pure garbage (all of them, head units and amps). Don't bother.

Couldn't agree more

dghii 11-22-2016 05:54 PM

If you want to keep your current stereo and add BT for calls and music,look at the iSimple Tranzit Blu. The unit is about $80 and connects quite easily...power, ground, antenna in and antenna out.

I bought one for my Boxster but ended up using it in my 2002 4Runner. The unit works great, pairs immediately and sound fine.

JayG 11-22-2016 06:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by particlewave (Post 517433)
You can't run speakers straight off of the OEM units. Without an amp, the sound output would be nil.

The OEM equipment is pure garbage (all of them, head units and amps). Don't bother.

Sorry, but that is not correct ( you can't run speakers off the OEM radio)
I don't know if I would say pure garbage, but certainly not the best available

The amp was an option and the radios have speaker outputs

I have no amp and once I added the rear speakers, even with the top down, it is decent, not stellar by any means, but not that bad either

particlewave 11-22-2016 06:17 PM

A $40 JVC "radio" would be better :p
Or an old school boom box sitting in the passenger seat. A decent head unit can be bought for under $100 and still be 10x better than the best CDR-whatever.

Seriously.

But as long as you like yours...

stelan 11-22-2016 08:48 PM

CDR OEM unit is bad but the OEM amp is worst, any aftermarket head unit will have better output than OEM head unit and OEM amp combined
(Bad as in low output)

BrokenLinkage 11-22-2016 09:01 PM

Counterpoint:
I have the oem head unit with amp & dash + door + rear speakers. Aside from the common sticky buttons, and a volume knob that is sometimes a little balky when it is freezing, I am well-pleased with it. It is sonically good, particularly through the midrange which is for all practical purposes about all you can enjoy in a moving convertible. It is visually inobtrusive, which is my preference - I didn't buy this car to play video games or place distractions in the cockpit. It is 15 yrs old, and has aged better than most of the various head units I've had in other cars, both oem and aftermarket. I thought I missed bluetooth, until I installed a motorola unit, then discovered I really don't like using it in the Box anyway. I prefer rotary knobs, and the ones on the oem Becker have just enough damping to be easy to use while in motion, and have a quality feel. Most functions can be controlled via tactile buttons/knobs without taking my eyes off the road, unlike most modern units.
For the record, I am neither deaf nor stupid, and first took an interest in high fidelity audio around 1981. I enjoy music immensely, but math will tell you I am not a teenager, and I no longer obsess over making a studio of my vehicles. (Nothing wrong with overkill in any endeavor, including mobile sound, just not central to my enjoyment of my cars these days.)
If optimum sound for the $ is the goal, I would say there is more room for improvement with 1st speakers, then amp, then acoustic damping/nvr, then head unit and wiring.
While features like bluetooth and inputs or music libraries can be fairly easily added to the oem unit, it will take either time on your behalf or purchased expertise to do so, and it may prove easier to simply update the head unit. Good luck on getting one as reliable and cosmetically sympathetic as the oem, though.
To each his own.

keeters 11-23-2016 02:51 AM

Thanks you for the replies.

I really like the simplicity of the OEM head units looks. It blends in with the simplicity of the cockpit. I would prefer not to change it. Knowing the many limitations of upgrading the MOST system has led me to the CDR-220.

I already have replacement speakers from CAI (the Hertz option). If I used a high quality aftermarket amp with the CDR-220 won't there be a great improvement?

Best
Brad

DrCactus 11-23-2016 05:27 AM

If I replaced the OEM AMP would it make any huge improvement in the OEM speakers/deck ? Just curious if replacing just one item could make a big difference

thom4782 11-23-2016 06:10 AM

As a platform, Boxsters are weak so you're starting off behind the curve. Better speaker enclosures and dampening material like Dynamat the dash, doors and rear shelf will help.

Once you've improved the platform, your system will only be as good as your weakest component. For me, a great head unit that provide multiple adjustments - frequency, time alignment, individual speaker amplification, crossover adjustment - is the best place to start so you can tune your system for the sound you like. Great head units these days come with bells and whistles like Bluetooth, car play etc. Next for me is great speakers and last of all is a great amp.

Here's my system. It sounds as good as any I've heard - must admit, however, Apple Car Play is quirky in the Pioneer

Pioneer AVIC7200 head unit
Audison SRx 5 channel amp
4 Focal K2 100 KRS in dash and rear shelf
2 Focal K2 165 KRXs in the doors

Sound deadening in the inner and outer door panels as well as the dash
Two flush mounted USB ports in bat wing for Apple car play and Android auto
Phone mic mounted on steering wheel between wheel and instrument cluster
Tuned amp and crossovers via frequency mapping

Chuck W. 11-23-2016 06:49 AM

I am lucky. I have no ear for sound quality. And, I won't touch or use the phone while in the Boxster. And, I prefer the look of the OEM radio over after market units. I have the digital sound system that is useless. It does, however, fill up one of the cubbies.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2...psirg9vngm.jpg

kk2002s 11-23-2016 07:07 AM

These are the speakers I listen to the most

http://986forum.com/forums/uploads02...1479916635.jpg

But when I am doing long hwy stretches I do like to listen to music
I read all these threads about replacing and how awful the stock unit is.
Its a Convertible!!!
How good could the sound ever be top up and especially top down even with the most expensive system?
Fortunately I have the upgraded unit with sub-woofer 6-cd changer in the frunk. This unit works really well with the top down, and of course top up

It does miss out on external connections but trying to use those while driving... I might as well be texting

Let the Flat Six orchestra play on

achillies 11-23-2016 07:38 AM

Will a CDR220 work in a car with MOST? The 03 radio to amp is a fiber cable. Wont the backdate radio require new wiring to work with the OEM speakers? If that is true why not update?

Fintro11 11-23-2016 07:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kk2002s (Post 517489)
These are the speakers I listen to the most

http://986forum.com/forums/uploads02...1479916635.jpg

But when I am doing long hwy stretches I do like to listen to music
I read all these threads about replacing and how awful the stock unit is.
Its a Convertible!!!
How good could the sound ever be top up and especially top down even with the most expensive system?
Fortunately I have the upgraded unit with sub-woofer 6-cd changer in the frunk. This unit works really well with the top down, and of course top up

It does miss out on external connections but trying to use those while driving... I might as well be texting

Let the Flat Six orchestra play on

This, I looked into replacing the cdr23 just so I could listen to music off my iPhone. After upgrading my exhaust I find I never have the radio on anyways just the sweet song of high reva

BrokenLinkage 11-23-2016 08:07 AM

Keeters - yes the amp will help a lot.
If you don't alreadyhave the rear shelf speakers and door woofers, add them at the same time. The oem amp is ok, if only b/c its freq cutoff for the door woofers is built in, but you can sonically do better with an aftermarket amp ( that will, like many mods, perform better than oem and cost way more,but actually subtract slightly from the perceived value of the car). If you go aftermarket amp, you can add frequency equalization / speaker time alignment / sub crossovers then. But I personally would get more fun out of any of a number of mechanical mods, for that money.
In any event, you will have to add conventional wiring from the head unit to to the amp, to replace the fiber optic MOST system wiring that you have now.

keeters 11-23-2016 08:15 AM

I want to keep the stock look in my car, I want to add bluetooth for calls and music.

I don't think that can be done with my current MOST/CDR23 system. If there is a workaround to add bluetooth to the current setup please let me know.

As an alternative, I would buy a CDR-220 head unit, and a quality aftermarket amp, Could I add bluetooth to that setup?

Best,
Brad

BrokenLinkage 11-23-2016 08:34 AM

I believe Dension makes a unit that will work with your current setup - for a price of several hundred bucks.
There are multinumerous options to add BT for the standard wiring of the cdr220.

mikesz 11-23-2016 09:22 AM

WOW! I replaced my factory radio with a Chinese DD off Ebay it was $240. Replaced the 4 channel amp with a 6 channel amp from a 996 Cabrio. Replaced the speakers in the Dash with a pair I bought for $29.95. Replaced the door speakers with a pair of MB Quart speakers I had sitting in my garage. Bought 2 pairs of Pioneer 4 inch speakers to put in my rear cubby cost about $70-$80 for the 2 pair. Had a pair of 4x6 Pioneer speakers also put them in the cubby in the center. Sold the factory radio for $150. The system sounds terrific. I have an aftermarket exhaust and with the top down at 100 I can hear music just fine. The only complaint I have is the radio reception but that might be the antenna connection in the passenger side. I have a backup camera, Bluetooth for my cell, cd player, thumb drive, GPS. I was very happy with the outcome and didn't cost me a fortune.

achillies 11-23-2016 09:22 AM

I used this until I changed my HU. Inexpensive and worked great.


https://www.walmart.com/ip/17729201


http://986forum.com/forums/uploads02/11479925314.jpg

keeters 11-23-2016 10:18 AM

I know that I can replace the head unit and go crazy if I wanted to. What I want is bluetooth with a factory head unit (I am a bit anal about keeping the stock appearance, I have even considered the Porsche Classic Navigation Head Unit for $1,200 but haven't seen it installed in a 986).

It appears that removing the MOST CDR23 and MOST amp and replacing with a CDR-220 with an aftermarket amp is the best route.

Thanks,
Brad

achillies 11-23-2016 11:40 AM

There is another option although a little pricy...The Denison units. They add allthe bells and whistles to a MOST car.

https://www.bumperplugs.com/index.php?route=product/product&product_id=125

Giller 11-23-2016 03:04 PM

Why is it you need Bluetooth? If for your phone, just pull over for the odd phone call. These cars are for driving, two hands on the wheel and focus on the road. The 220 isn't going to give you much more in the way of music enhancement, and I believe the Bluetooth aspect is pretty poor anyways....
It's also not overly expensive, so worth the shot.

10/10ths 11-23-2016 06:00 PM

Keep stock head unit...
 
....and install this:

https://www.amazon.com/iSimple-Hands-Free-Calling-Streaming-Smartphones/dp/B00FRU5UNA/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1479956367&sr=8-2&keywords=iSimple

jonogt6 11-24-2016 05:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by particlewave (Post 517433)
You can't run speakers straight off of the OEM units. Without an amp, the sound output would be nil.

The OEM equipment is pure garbage (all of them, head units and amps). Don't bother.

Ahem that's a bit of a sweeping statement!

Fortunately whoever purchased my 99 Boxster originally specified the full fat sound pack with Front and rear 6 Speaker system & DSP etc. It sounds far from garbage & is really rather good!

As with all old Porsche options you pays yer money and takes yer choice.

keeters 11-24-2016 05:06 AM

It looks like the iSimple Tranzit Blu requires an aux port. I don't believe the CDR23 has an aux port.

10/10ths 11-24-2016 05:38 PM

Keeters...
 
...Negative, Ghostrider!

The iSimple Transit Blu uses either a jack OR it plugs into your FM antenna port.

You bluetooth your phone to the unit, and it bypasses the FM antenna and plays your music over a chosen FM frequency.

Works great!

I have one in my '04 SE with BOSE and MOST.

Good luck.

dghii 11-24-2016 06:47 PM

+1 on previous post. I use the Tranzit Blu HF through the antenna ports and it works fine. I would anticipate that sound quality through AUX would be better as the signal is not modulated/demodulated. Not bad anyway.

BoomerRoadie 11-24-2016 06:53 PM

I too would prefer to maintain the look of the factory deck, but it would be nice to have bluetooth ability. I found this, but I have yet to try it out. But this is what I plan on doing. Take a look:

AUX-BKR Auxiliay input Jack for Select Becker Radios with CD Changer :: Auxiliary Input Adapters

or

3.5-BKRCD Auxiliay input Adapter for Becker Radios with CD Changer :: Auxiliary Input Adapters

Plus you'll want this: BRRT Becker Radio Removal Tools :: Accessories

I intend on getting the one that adds the AUX female plug that I'll install somewhere in the cockpit. This particular one requires that the CD changer remains connected and operational. The internal software in the stereo deck already have the previsions for an AUX input.

It's not an ideal BT connection because it will only be BT connected when in AUX mode, but for purposes of streaming music, it'll work just fine. On the other hand, say you're listening to the radio and a call comes in, it will not be BT connected (only when you're in AUX mode).

This is how I understand the system to work, but again, I have yet to actual do the install. If you like this and beat me to it, please do tell!!

Good luck,

Pilot2519j 11-26-2016 07:13 AM

I wanted to modernize my radio and by the time my questions were answered I was not going to buy a new stereo for 600 to 1000. after much pondering I bought a motorola bluetooth from Verizon that worked with my samsung smartphone and I downloaded pandora, sirius and it plays through the stereo speakers. The output is most of the time perfect except sometimes powerlines will give static but that is rarely. A lot cheaper than buying a new stereo. Another plus is that since it is working through the bluetooth and car speakers you can modulate the voice output better. I have to say that since we are all enamored with the audio output of the engine the quality of the stereo is secondary. Really, top down cruising at 85 the wind , the noise who cares about the stereo just crank it high. That's the Boxster ride enjoying the elements.

WRR986 05-31-2017 01:07 AM

4 Attachment(s)
Hi thom4782

Noticed you have some 6.5 K2's in the doors.
Was just wondering how they fitted in.
This was my gumtree project. My model car is a 986
Currently I have 130 K2's in the doors, was an easy job, I just fabricated a ply board panel slapped some of that sound deadener stuff on the doors and skins.
Placed the tweeters in the original speaker area on the dash (I was running 4 inch on the dash before going fully active - but even then it was a hell of a fit "way to close to the air bag on the left" - just running the tweeters up there was a great choice)
Didn’t want to go passive because those crossovers are massive.
So got the DEH-80PRs because it had the crossovers built into the head unit, (but I did think very strongly about integrating the original face plate and pushing the DEH-80 back a bit because I like the stock look too
I also modelled up and fabricated an amp bracket in the front boot, to take 2 of JL-DX400/4 amps
Even got my daughter to jump in the boot with the go pro for final checks once the amps were fitted (8 year olds really come in handy some time)
Used one amp bridged to run the 130 K2 main drivers. Second amp used two channels to run the tweeters from the K2 set.
That left me two channels to bridge for the sub, but was still doing planning on how I would set up the sub and were to put it?
At this stage before the sub was fitted the end result was stunning with full sound more than enough. Total clarity. – Actually I couldn’t get the smile off my face (just lacked a bit of deep notes)
BUT NONE OF THE ABOVE IS WERE THE JOURNEY BEGAN
before I used the right stuff as per above, I tried the newer head unit, did the hack with input plug for iPhone music, did the Bluetooth hack, got the full Bose package “WHAT A WAIST OF TIME AND MONEY” but totally worth the lesson.
Hit the local car audio shop to get some tips and ideas on the sub, they advised me to throw it down near the passenger’s feet. “That wasn’t going to happen” I like the passenger to be comfy too.
So with the rear parcel tray thingy I created a plaster mould and formed my own custom fibreglass sub box I’m running an 8 inch shallow Rockford high end. Once all setup it was totally awesome for me. (The only thing I don’t like about the sub is I can since the cone moving!) so am hoping to replace the 8 inch with two 13WS 5inch utopia.)
Anyway I blew one of my 130K2’s up.
And am looking at Focal 165 KRXS K2 to take their place, if you could give some pointers I would really appreciate it cheers

dghii 05-31-2017 06:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Giller (Post 517524)
Why is it you need Bluetooth? If for your phone, just pull over for the odd phone call. These cars are for driving, two hands on the wheel and focus on the road. The 220 isn't going to give you much more in the way of music enhancement, and I believe the Bluetooth aspect is pretty poor anyways....
It's also not overly expensive, so worth the shot.

This isn't the 50's!
Bluetooth works great for both phone and audio streaming. It is very inexpensive at this point as well. BT audio is, at worst, FM quality. At best, BT is between FM and CD.

You can always drive with radio and phone off, but when not in the twilight zone, BT is a very nice, modern day capability to have in any car.

Full disclosure: I control door locks and thermostats from my phone, along with securly accepting credit cards!


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:36 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2025 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Pelican Parts Website